Mayo TDs clash with Government over proposed energy windfall tax in Dáil

placeholder image
Local Library

Rose Conway-Walsh and Paul Lawless back Social Democrats motion calling for €400 energy credit, while Government rejects proposal

Mayo TDs Rose Conway-Walsh and Paul Lawless have backed calls for a windfall tax on energy companies as the Dáil debated measures to tackle rising household energy costs.

The Social Democrats motion called for the Government to reintroduce a market revenue cap and temporary solidarity contribution on excess energy profits, with the proceeds used to provide a targeted €400 energy credit to households earning up to €70,000.

The motion was debated in the Dáil on Wednesday, September 30, against a backdrop of concerns about rising energy costs and household arrears.

Deputy Conway-Walsh said people across Mayo were struggling with the cost of heating their homes, particularly older people, people with disabilities, people with chronic illnesses and families facing financial pressure.

She said energy companies were continuing to record substantial profits while households were experiencing difficulties paying their bills.

“Tá an geimhreadh ag teacht. The winter is coming,” she told the Dáil, adding that the Government should introduce a windfall tax, restore energy credits and reform the energy market.

“Week in, week out, across Mayo, I meet [people] and families who are genuinely afraid to use electricity or to put the heating on,” Deputy Conway-Walsh said. “Some of these people will sit cold in their own homes because they are terrified of the bill coming through the door.”

The Sinn Féin TD also pointed to the Corrib gas project in Mayo and the €377 million profits reported by the majority State-owned ESB, arguing that the Government could take action to support households.

“Ireland has some of the highest household electricity prices in the EU. Record numbers of households are in arrears with their electricity bills while private energy companies make millions and billions in profits. That includes the Corrib gas project,” she said.

Deputy Paul Lawless also supported the motion, focusing on the relationship between wholesale electricity prices and the design of the electricity market.

He said the profits being generated by energy companies should be used to benefit consumers when those profits were driven by high energy prices.

“If a company is making supernatural profits as a result of war and the design of the market, those profits should return to consumers,” he told the Dáil. “The profits are certainly there.”

“We have an extraordinary situation whereby we have record profits at the top and record arrears at the bottom. Ordinary families at the bottom are suffering. One in seven households across this State are struggling with electricity bills,” he added.

The Aontú TD argued that electricity prices can be influenced by the most expensive generation source in the market, generally gas, meaning renewable generators can receive higher revenues when gas prices rise.

“The price of electricity is not set by the cost of making electricity. It is set by the most expensive plant in terms of the auction system and that is generally always gas,” Deputy Lawless said.

“When the price of gas goes through the roof, wind farms and solar operators are paid the same sky-high price, even though the cost of wind and sun did not change and has not changed. That is the windfall we speak of.”

The motion cited figures including ESB pre-tax profits of €445.6 million in the first half of 2026, Energia pre-tax profits of €70 million in the second quarter and Bord Gáis Energy pre-tax profits of €50 million in the first six months of the year.

The motion also cited Commission for Regulation of Utilities figures showing more than 323,000 Irish households were in electricity arrears in June.

The Government rejected the motion and put forward its own countermotion. Minister of State Christopher O’Sullivan said the Government recognised the pressure being placed on households and was already taking measures to address energy costs.

He pointed to measures including reduced VAT on gas and electricity, social protection supports and increased funding for SEAI home energy upgrades.

He also highlighted new supports for battery storage and measures designed to make retrofitting more accessible to households.

On windfall taxation, Minister O’Sullivan said the Government was considering the issue through its National Energy Affordability Taskforce and would continue to engage at EU level.

He said the Government was ready to respond as circumstances evolved, while arguing that the longer-term solution was to reduce Ireland’s dependence on imported fossil fuels through renewable energy, energy efficiency and increased interconnection.

The Minister also said the Government would continue to monitor energy prices and household affordability ahead of the forthcoming Budget.

The Social Democrats’ motion was not accepted by the Government, with the division on the Government amendment postponed until the weekly division time.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice