'We have to take a stand' on legal aid dispute says Mayo solictor

Solicitor Cathy McDarby says solicitors had to take a stand on legal aid disputeplaceholder image
Solicitor Cathy McDarby says solicitors had to take a stand on legal aid dispute | Local Library

Ballinrobe-based solicitor Cathy McDarby calls for Minister for Justice to sit down with solicitors to resolve legal aid dispute

A MAYO solicitor involved in the walk out of Castlebar Circuit Court described as absurd the failure of the Minister for Justice to mediate with solicitors and bring an end to the legal aid dispute.

Solicitors in Mayo staged a mass walk-out of Castlebar Courthouse on the first day of the October sittings of Castlebar Circuit Criminal Court as part of a legal aid dispute with the Department of Justice.

Ballinrobe-based solicitor Cathy McDarby who was part of the walk-out told The Mayo News that solicitors felt they had no choice but to stage the protest and they had to take a stand.

“We felt we had no other choice. We have been desperately calling for mediation and talks for months now but to no avail and to no response. We have to take a stand. We see victims in court today, we see accused people in court and the stress on them. We want to be back in court but we had to do something and what else can we do. I tried talking and we tried begging and asking but we got no response,” she said.

Mayo solicitors withdrew their services for criminal cases following the decision of the Minister for Justice to replace the previous legal aid fee structure with a flat fee covering a fixed number of court appearances on July 1. They have since withdrawn from the legal aid panel and refuse to deal with criminal cases in courts in Mayo.

The Law Society have been calling for the Minister for Justice, Jim O'Callaghan to take part in talks to resolve the dispute but there is no indication he will be amenable to it. Ms McDarby said she could not understand the stance the Minister is taking and called for him to engage in meaningful engagement and to stop ignoring the dispute.

“We would be thrilled for mediation and an independent person to look at it would be perfect. One has to wonder why the Minister who is part of a government that brought in mediation and is refusing to mediate. Especially in the light of the fact that another government minister is calling for talks on the work stoppages and national day of strike. You have one minister who is saying disputes can only be resolved by talks and another minister absolutely refusing to talk. It is absolutely absurd to me to be honest.

“I cannot understand why we are here. We are all trained negotiators but you cannot negotiate against the wall and that is what we have been asked to do at the moment. The minister who is a senior counsel is an exceptionally trained negotiator and surely he should surely know how to negotiate and end this.

“It is innocent people who are suffering and we do not want that. We work long hours for our clients and we are anxious to help them but we cannot if we are not talked to. You cannot negotiate against yourself,” she said.

President of the Mayo Solicitors Bar Association, Gary Mulchrone warned that solicitors impacted by the dispute will leave criminal law practice if it continues.

“I regret the impact on the court and I regret to say that this dispute has potentially caused irreparable damage to the appetite of some committed professional solicitors to work in this area of criminal law. Some might permanently turn their back on their practice in this area as their work might be better appreciated and better remunerated elsewhere,” he said.

Ms McDarby agreed, saying that solicitors' practices in the west of Ireland are part of the circular economy and many people and businesses depend on them.

“We have staff to pay and rates to pay and solicitors in small practices in the west of Ireland are in a circular economy. If we are not getting money in it is not just us...It is every shop you go to, it is all the places our staff shop in. I have 15 staff and they are all relying on us to bring in their wages and their wages go to local economies,” she said.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice