Judge says court system in Mayo is approaching a crisis point


Judge Eoin Garavan makes comments after solicitors walk out of court on the first day of the October sittings of Castlebar Circuit Court
A Mayo judge has called on both sides in the legal aid dispute to engage in meaningful dialogue to resolve the matter after commenting that the court in Mayo faces being overwhelmed with unheard cases.
Solicitors in Mayo held a walkout of Castlebar Courthouse on the first day of the October sessions of the Castlebar Circuit Criminal Court this morning (Monday) having announced they were withdrawing their services while the legal aid dispute with the Department of Justice remains unresolved.
The October sittings of the Castlebar Circuit Criminal Court is to last for six weeks with 180 cases due to be heard over those weeks. Many of these cases involved defendants facing a trial but members of the jury panel who were due to sit on juries over the next week were sent home after being told by Judge Eoin Garavan that they would not be needed because of the current dispute.
The legal aid dispute has been ongoing since July 1 when the Minister for Justice replaced the previous legal aid fee structure with a flat fee covering a fixed number of court appearances.
Since then, solicitors in Mayo and in other parts of the country have withdrawn their services in criminal cases leading to a backlog in cases.
While indicating he was remaining neutral in the dispute, Judge Garavan said that the ongoing impasse was causing a crisis in the court system and called for both sides to engage in meaningful dialogue.
“All I can do as one circuit court judge of many in this country is to call on both sides for meaningful dialogue. We are now in a situation in Castlebar where it is becoming a crisis and is critical and akin to the Covid situation. But at least during Covid crime was reduced for obvious reasons. In this case the lists are not being done but the crime is presumingly is operating at the same levels.
“There are 180 cases and I have no idea how many will be done in these sessions, if any at all. We had about 13 or 14 new returns since the end of July and they add to the list and presuming there will be a similar number between now and the next list in February. It is going to be potentially overwhelming for the court and certainly those now appearing in the list can expect many years before their cases can be dealt with and that is unacceptable.
“As far as I am concerned the position in Mayo is now getting critical and I can only hope that meaningful talks in this dispute can be resolved as soon as possible. There are too many people not working and too many cases not being finalised and that is not an acceptable situation,” he said.
Earlier, Gary Mulchrone, President of the Mayo Solicitors Bar Association informed Judge Garavan that all solicitors in Mayo have withdrawn from the legal aid panel and they would not be in a position to deal with cases in the circuit court.
“Solicitors will not be in a position to deal with cases while this dispute remains and regrettably solicitors have decided they will be withdrawing from the court for all such cases. Each person has made that decision themselves individually and obviously it will have an enormous impact not just on the list for this term but the next term and beyond,” he said.
.jpeg?crop=3:2,smart&trim=&width=640&quality=65)

The court heard that the only cases solicitors would be dealing with were cases where defendants have been in custody before the introduction of the new legal aid scheme in July.
Mr Mulchrone said that opposition to the new legal aid scheme was flagged well in advance with the Department of Justice and everyone working in the cort system was feeling the pain.
“Everyone working in the system is feeling the pain and understands the impact of this dispute but yet it would appear it is being downplayed and typified by a failure to engage and resolve and medicate which has been quite striking.
“Last term we lost four weeks of work and this upcoming term looks to be similarly imperiled. There are a total of 181 cases listed for trial or for sentence or indication of a plea across the sessions and this does not include the district court appeals list. The trial list for each of the weeks assigned has ballooned and behind each of these cases are multiple impacted parties.
“I am sorry to see so many people needlessly discommoded by this period of upheaval and I know my colleagues in the Bar [barristers] have been deeply hurt as well by this dispute and colleagues across the county have suffered for over four months with no income from the work in this area.
“Jobs depend on this income, local jobs and local people and yet it seems there is no recognition for that and I am astounded that this disruption has now become the norm over the last four months.
“I do hope we will return soon but the answer to that question does not lie with us, it lies squarely at the feet of one person who could end the dispute today if he so wished,” he said.
Barrister Dairmuid Connolly told the court that he echoed the comments of Mr Mulchrone and barristers were supporting their solicitor colleagues in the dispute. He said the impasse has created difficulties for a lot of people but also for victims and witnesses and that people who should be in prison are at liberty because their sentencing hearings cannot be heard.
“There is a myth out there that the courts are working properly but this is just not tenable. I understand there were three legal aid certs completed last term in a four week session. There are 54 plus cases before you today and I don't believe any of them will be in a position to progress. To say the courts are functioning normally or appropriately is just not correct,” he said, adding that dialogue is needed to bring the dispute to an end.
“It is clear that every dispute comes to an end and we hope that the Minister sits down and engages with our solicitor colleagues in dialogue to resolve this issue that goes to the heart of criminal justice that clients are entitled to proper legal representation which is provided at the highest level by our solicitor colleagues and we urge the minister to do the right thing and end this dispute.”
