FILM REVIEW: The Proposal

A fairly well-baked Alaskaplaceholder image
A fairly well-baked Alaska

The Proposal manages to produce some proper laughs in its first half before the romantic goo inevitably sets in.

We look at the Mayo minors of 1999 and ask: where are they now?placeholder image
We look at the Mayo minors of 1999 and ask: where are they now?

Daniel Carey

WHEN Sarah Palin announced her resignation as Governor of Alaska, the Republican media consultant Todd Harris suggested that she was on the verge of becoming the ‘Miami Vice’ of American politics – ‘something a lot of people once thought was cool and then 20 years later look back, shake their heads and just kind of laugh’.

‘The Proposal’, a romantic comedy starring Sandra Bullock and Ryan Reynolds, is largely set in Palin’s home state. It may actually stand the test of time rather better than the former US Vice-Presidential candidate – or ‘Miami Vice’, for that matter.

Unlike many other movies in a generally forgettable if lucrative genre, ‘The Proposal’ manages to produce some proper laughs in its first half before the romantic goo inevitably sets in later on.

Margaret Tate (Bullock) is the slave-driving editor-in-chief of a publishing house, and Andrew Paxton (Reynolds) is her put-upon assistant. She has no life outside the office and expects him to be at her beck and call. When she’s threatened with deportation to Canada, she convinces him to marry her so she can stay in the country. It’s ‘Green Card’ meets ‘The Devil Wears Prada’, and if you can accept the central premise (or get over Andrew’s acceptance of it), it’s not a bad night out.

Andrew faces unemployment unless he agrees to the wedding, but is rather alarmed to learn that he faces a substantial fine or jail-time if it’s proven to be a marriage of convenience. They head to his folks’ place for the weekend (in Alaska) with the promise of a Monday-morning grilling from suspicious immigration official Mr Gilbertson (Denis O’Hare).

Having spent years being dominated by Margaret, Andrew feels it’s pay-back time, and takes advantage of his new-found power. His family, whom he rarely sees, are surprised to find that the woman he dubbed ‘Satan’s mistress’ is now his fiancée. “I never figured you for someone who slept your way to the middle,” his gruff father Joe (Craig T Nelson) notes. His mother Grace (Mary Steenburgen) attempts to show her daughter-in-law-to-be a good time with the help of a store clerk who doubles as a waiter and a male stripper. But former Golden Girl Betty White (still hale and hearty at 87) really steals the show as Andrew’s streetwise grandmother Annie.

They’re clearly a wealthy clan, and Margaret wants to know why Andrew didn’t tell her he was ‘some kind of Alaskan Kennedy’. “Well,” he replies deliberately, “we were in the middle of talking about you – for the last three years.” There’s some amusing gender-bending, role reversing and quiet seething on both their parts. Director Anne Fletcher has some fun with the mores of modern relationships, as when Andrew must leap from his position on the floor into bed with Margaret after his mother announces that she’s coming into their room with breakfast in bed.

Lest we get carried away with ourselves, yes, it is more of a girls’ film, and yes, romance trumps comedy in the second half. But then, ’twas ever thus, and if the ultimate destination is predictable, at least the twists and turns along the way are reasonably interesting.

To those of us with a fondness for motion pictures involving maverick cops with hearts of gold, ‘The Proposal’ offers a line that may live in infamy. “I think Brian Dennehy is sexy,” Margaret says to her betrothed as part of a long list of her likes and dislikes. Bullock and a 71-year-old man who, as Jack Reed, searched for justice with a badge of honour, are surely an even more unlikely couple than Bullock and Reynolds

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice