FILM REVIEW: Bandslam

No Grand Slam, but a Triple Crown, maybeplaceholder image
No Grand Slam, but a Triple Crown, maybe

With references to the Velvet Underground, Samuel Beckett and Jane Austen, this is not your average teen flick.

We look at the Mayo minors of 1999 and ask: where are they now?placeholder image
We look at the Mayo minors of 1999 and ask: where are they now?

Daniel Carey

THERE’S a great scene in ‘The Simpsons’ where Ralph Wiggum, interviewed by Krusty the Klown on live television, reveals that he loves Lisa Simpson and plans to marry her. A horrified Lisa screams ‘No!’ and admits that she only gave him a Valentine’s Day card because nobody else would. Afterwards, Lisa’s brother Bart plays her back the tape of the show in slow motion, and reveals that ‘you can actually pinpoint the exact second where his heart rips in two!’

I’m not sure I can be that specific about the moment when ‘Bandslam’ went into Bizarro World, but it did lose me about two-thirds of the way through and never got me back. To be fair, however, this new film from director Todd Graff is a good deal better than you might expect.

Although owing something to ‘School of Rock’, the main character is not a charismatic teacher, but a music-obsessed, introverted teenager named Will Burton (Gaelen Connell). Bullied at his old school (‘Guantanamo with a lunch period’), he moves to New Jersey and discovers a Battle of the Bands competition which he likens to ‘a Nuremberg rally produced by MTV’.

He is befriended by Sa5m – the 5 is silent – played by Vanessa Hudgens, who warns him that going up against the existing school band would be ‘like burning the American flag’. But, at the urging of an ex-cheerleader, Charlotte (Aly Michalka), he agrees to transform a three-piece outfit and have a cut at Bandslam, the competition of the title.

Sa5m warns Will about Charlotte, though Hudgens – fresh from three rounds with Zac Efron in the ‘High School Musical’ saga – is rather too pretty to be a convincing underdog. And quite how a maddeningly introspective ugly duckling ends up with the two funkiest rock chicks in the school is something you will ask yourself more than once.

The funniest leitmotif running through ‘Bandslam’ is Will’s frequent, unanswered emails to his hero. “Dear David Bowie,” he says as Charlotte and her colleagues await his initial response to their musical efforts, “how do you tell Pinocchio that he’ll never be a real boy?”

With references to the Velvet Underground, Samuel Beckett and Jane Austen, this is not your average teen flick. Throw in a benign breaking-and-entering scene at CBGB’s in New York, where Will gives Sa5m a potted history of punk and what followed, and there may be something for accompanying parents to enjoy too.

The leads are likeable, and there are some decent tunes featured. The script – particularly in the first half – is witty and provides a surprising number of laugh-out-loud moments. “You ever feel like Clark Kent?” Will asks the drummer he wants to sign up, whose reluctant suggestion that he listen to a demo of the band is dismissed as no better than ‘licking the pages of a cookbook’. There’s also an amusing step-by-step guide to snogging, and a spectacularly badly-executed kiss. Just to make ‘Friends’ fans feel old, Lisa Kudrow turns up as Will’s mother.

Coming-of-age dramas generally follow a certain pattern – hero is lonely and struggling for a purpose; hero finds company and develops; hero has huge falling-out with new friend(s); and then finally things work themselves out. The late low before the inevitable high was where ‘Bandslam’ jumped the shark for this viewer. What follows involves mindless verbal abuse, questionable motivation, and a supposedly heartfelt song from a self-confessed phoney. To paraphrase ‘Jerry Maguire’: “You lost me at goodbye”. Which is unfortunate, because this picture has a lot going for it. ‘Bandslam’ is not a Grand Slam, but it just might be a Triple Crown.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice