A headline that decided the Presidency


When Gerald Ford refused to bail out NYC, a newspaper headline read: “FORD TO CITY: DROP DEAD”.
ENDORSING a book when you’re just over halfway through it can be a dangerous business. But if the final 150 pages of ‘Ladies And Gentlemen, The Bronx Is Burning’ are anything like the first 200, it’ll be the best thing I’ve read this year.
Subtitled ‘1977, Baseball, Politics, And The Battle For The Soul Of A City’, it tells the story of a momentous year in New York history. Two epic battles form the centrepiece – the fight between New York Yankees player Reggie Jackson and team manager Billy Martin, and the race to be city mayor between Mario Cuomo and Ed Koch.
Throw in the murders committed by the figure dubbed the ‘Son of Sam’, the opening of Studio 54, the blackout which prompted widespread looting, and Rupert Murdoch’s acquisition of the New York Post, and it’s clear that author Jonathan Mahler had plenty of good material to work with. But the way he brought all these threads together in this 2005 publication is fascinating.
Most of the events described in the book take place, unsurprisingly, in 1977. But one of the biggest laughs the reader is liable to get from it comes from events that occurred in 1975. In October of that year, New York City government was facing bankruptcy and the Mayor, Abe Beame, went to Washington seeking a bailout. US President Gerald Ford refused to provide financial assistance, leading to a front-page headline in the Daily News which has become the stuff of legend: “FORD TO CITY: DROP DEAD”.
Rather bizarrely, Wikipedia’s entry for the Daily News says that the newspaper subsequently endorsed Ford for President. But that 144-point headline, set in huge bold letters, clearly had more of an effect on readers than its later support for the Republican incumbent. Ford later acknowledged that it almost certainly lost him New York State in his 1976 race against Jimmy Carter, and with it, the presidency.
The Democratic Party candidate got huge backing from urban voters, and New York subway cars and buses were festooned with posters of the smiling Southerner and his solemn vow – “I guarantee that if I go to the White House, I’ll never tell the people of the greatest city on earth to drop dead’.
Fast forward to 2005, and the man responsible for that headline, William J Brink … dropped dead. The 89-year-old, who lived in Westport, Conneticut, was a former managing editor of the Daily News. All of the obituaries referred to his most famous headline which. The New York Times noted, was ‘displayed on the three major television networks’ in the US and was ‘reproduced in newspapers around the world’.
Being the serious sort, another media organ in The Big Apple had to resist saying Brink had dropped dead, but did poke fun at itself in the final line of its tribute. “The corresponding headline in The New York Times that day, FORD, CASTIGATING CITY, ASSERTS HE’D VETO FUND GUARANTEE; OFFERS BANKRUPTCY BILL, remains unsung,” the paper of record noted dryly.