Twenty years on from THAT game


FOOTBALL Twenty years on, Anthony Finnerty discusses the most dramatic Mayo-Roscommon game in history – the 1989 Connacht SFC final replay in Dr Hyde Park.
Twenty years on from THAT game


Daniel Carey
“WE kept the faith,” John O’Mahony said in the dressing-room after what’s regarded as the most dramatic game ever between Mayo and Roscommon. It’s a phrase that still reverberates, captured in the famous banner displayed after Mayo’s first All-Ireland final appearance in 38 years. But Anthony Finnerty admits to one moment of doubt before Mayo finally overcame Roscommon in the 1989 Connacht final replay.
A great first-half goal from Noel Durkin cancelled out Tony McManus’s penalty, and Mayo were four points up entering the closing stages. Then Vincent Glennon scored twice, and McManus was fouled. Referee Mickey Kearins awarded a second penalty, which McManus converted. Roscommon were one up.
“I still remember the sinking in the pit of my stomach,” Finnerty told The Mayo News, recalling that moment. “It was a feeling of horror, but we hardly had time to catch our breath when Gabriel Irwin took a quick kick-out.”
The ball went from TJ Kilgallon to John Finn, who sent it in high to Willie Joe Padden, who broke it down to Micheál Collins. The Lacken man, who had come on as a substitute for the injured Frank Noone, fired it into the net, but Kearins whistled play back for an infringement. Mayo were awarded a free, Michael Fitzmaurice popped it over, and the drama wasn’t finished yet.
“It was probably a minute or less than a minute between that [Tony McManus] goal and the ball hitting the net at the other end,” said Finnerty. “That’s the one incident in the whole year, I think, that sticks out in my mind, nearly more than anything else. I can still see Gabriel Irwin sprinting out, and he had the kick-out taken so quickly. We had the game lost at the death and then the whole thing turned again.”
Four Roscommon points – from Vincent Glennon, Eamon McManus, John Newton and Tony McManus – met with a single response from Liam McHale in the first half of extra time. Then Frank Noone left his stretcher and dragged himself across the pitch to exhort his team-mates to greater effort. “Once he had spoken,” John O’Mahony wrote in the 1989 Mayo GAA Yearbook, “no one else needed to say anything.”
Mayo shot seven wides in the second period of extra time, but with two minutes to go, Brian Kilkelly’s high ball was knocked down by Willie Joe Padden into Finnerty’s path. The Moygownagh man buried the ball in the net to level matters. Kevin McStay joked afterwards that it was the goal of the season but the super sub isn’t making any major claims for it 20 years on.
“It wasn’t a great goal by any means,” he recalls with a laugh. “I kicked it with my left foot and it was a sort of a half-kick, half-block that dribbled in over the line.”
Still, they all count, and a 40-yard beauty from Fitzmaurice left Mayo one up. There was still time for Jimmy Burke to famously seal the deal in a style that has been compared to a pushover try. Finnerty and McHale played their part in the move, and the Aghamore man ended up in the net – along with the ball. “It was like a slow-motion shot, hilarious stuff,” Finnerty says with a smile.
Liam McHale’s dad had passed away a week previously, and the Ballina man dedicated the victory to him. McHale had been outstanding in the opening two matches against Galway, and was superb in the Hyde – as was Mayo captain Jimmy Browne, who got concussion and was in an ambulance when the cup was presented to mark what is John O’Mahony’s most recent Connacht title as Mayo manager.
“I think that Liam McHale probably had his best 20 minutes of football for Mayo in that extra-time period,” Finnerty says. “That was one of his best performances ever in a Mayo jersey, because for long stages, Roscommon just couldn’t get the ball past McHale. Wherever they were kicking it, he seemed to be there. He was sweeping over across the pitch and he was just winning everything.”
The provincial title had been hard-earned. A draw in Tuam (“always a tough spot,” Finnerty comments) after Gay McManus’s late equaliser was followed by a replay in Castlebar, where Finnerty and McHale got goals – “We gave them a good beating,” is the curly-haired attacker’s honest assessment. Then came the Connacht final, a repeat of the 1988 fixture, but Mayo shot 14 wides in Castlebar, and had Gabriel Irwin to thank for an outstanding save from Paul Earley’s effort. Eventually it finished in a draw, late scores from TJ Kilgallon and Michael Fitzmaurice tying things up.
“They were always good, tough battles,” Finnerty says of Mayo-Roscommon duels in that era. “The replay was a great tussle. There were great personal rivalries too, particularly between Peter Ford and Paul Earley! The McManuses and Seán Maher had a bit of a thing going, I think. I played on Des Newton numerous times, and we had great banter.”
The prospect of a semi-final against the Ulster champions was an extra carrot for Mayo. In an decade when Leinster and Munster sides won every All-Ireland title, a tilt at the northerners was the best chance a Connacht side had of making it to the big dance. Mayo were relegated from Division 2 of the National League in the spring of 1989. But as the reigning provincial kingpins, they were optimistic about retaining their crown – and going further.
“Given that Connacht would have been playing Ulster in the semi-final, there were aspirations,” Finnerty says. “Galway had fluffed their chance in ’86 against Tyrone, but we felt ourselves that [1989] would be the year if we were ever going to get to an All-Ireland final. So there was an awful lot at stake in that Roscommon game.”
Cue victory over Tyrone, and the songs, banners and general mayhem that ensued before the All-Ireland final. Finnerty’s goal and miss against Cork are still discussed 20 years on. But that’s another story.
MAYO
G Irwin; J Browne, P Ford, D Flanagan; F Noone, TJ Kilgallon, J Finn; S Maher, L McHale (0-3); N Durkin (1-0), WJ Padden (0-2), R Dempsey; K McStay (0-2), J Burke (1-1), M Fitzmaurice (0-5).
Subs used: A Finnerty (1-1) for N Durkin; MJ Mullin for K McStay; M Carney for R Dempsey; M Collins for F Noone; M Feeney for J Browne; B Kilkelly for M Carney.
ROSCOMMON
G Sheerin; G Wynne, J Dowd, D Newton; J Connaughton, P McNeill, M Reilly; S Killoran (0-1), J Newton (0-1); D Brady, E McManus Jr (0-1), V Glennon (0-4); M Donlon, P Earley (0-2), T McManus (2-4).
Subs used: P Doorey for P Earley; P Earley for M Donlon; P Hickey for G Wynne; M Donlon for P Doorey; T Óg O’Brien for P McNeill.
Referee: M Kearins (Sligo)