Top Mayo GAA coach not in favour of Under-12 competition

Mayo GAA GDA coach Kieran Kilkennyplaceholder image
Mayo GAA GDA coach Kieran Kilkenny

HE’S the Performance Games Development Administrator (GDA) coach with Mayo GAA, a former Davitts forward who represented the county at minor and Under-21 level, and these days he’s also an underage club coach with St Brigid’s in Roscommon.

So Kieran Kilkenny is ideally placed to speak on the impact competition has on young footballers. He outlined his thoughts to The Mayo News recently.

Being immersed in the game as both a professional and a volunteer means Kilkenny gets to work with players across all participation levels and his insight is broad-ranging.

“In a pyramid system of involvement we have to have the largest possible numbers as a baseline, therefore creating the environment for full participation at an early age is key,” he explained. 

“One of the core values of the GAA is inclusion, and we have to stand by those values. If you impose competitive football at Under-12 level certain people may lose sight of those values. “If there’s competition at that age then the prospect of full participation goes out the window.

“A minority of coaches act on adult values, and when games are tight they forget about the participation element and get carried away. They would rather lose players than lose competitions. That leaves a lot of players watching on from the sidelines and that’s not what the GAA is about.”

Away from his day job with Mayo GAA, Kieran Kilkenny coaches one of the Under-12 teams in St Brigid’s where the club fields two teams, based completely on age rather than ability.

It is proving to be very successful. 

“At that age, lads want to play with their classmates and their friends and our Division 1 team is made up exclusively of lads born in 2011 and the Division 5 team of lads from 2012,” he said. “This gives everyone the time and space to develop and get game time.

“A recent survey in Britain asked children why they play sport? The most popular answer was ‘to have fun’ and the second most popular response was ‘to be with their friends’. “Winning or losing didn’t even feature in the responses and all adults involved at Under-12 level need to be aware of that. Some people remember their own time playing adult football instead of thinking about the enjoyment and full participation of their players. 

“Most U-12 teams are made up of lads in sixth, fifth and sometimes fourth class at school,” he added. “A lot of clubs pick what they see as their best players for their Under-12 team and the other lads are on the sideline. Larger clubs have two teams at Under-12 and also often pick what they see as their best players for the first team.

“Both these approaches mean that older lads might be left on the sideline while lads a year or two younger are on the team. We can only imagine how that makes those older lads feel, and it certainly doesn’t promote full participation because it sends out a message to some lads that they’re just not good enough.

“Attracting players to our games and retaining them means our base must be as wide as possible and that means creating an environment where players enjoy being involved at Under-12 level,” Kieran continued before saying that adults who give their time to teams do so with the best of intentions.

But education and understanding is a crucial component when helping with player development.

“The GAA is a volunteer organisation and we need everyone, but we must always be aware of what’s best for the player, especially at that age. Enjoyment is key and at that age the players just want to kick ball with their friends.

“I’m not against competition at all, there’s great value in it, but not at Under-12. There is plenty time for that in the following years. I think there’s a time to move into competitive football and that’s when secondary school starts. That seems the ideal and natural time.”

That approach would lead to Cumann na mBunscol competitions changing from their current status to non-competitive, all-inclusive tournaments.

The Mayo Performance GDA coach sees how this would be beneficial in the greater scheme of things.

“Cumann na mBunscol is brilliant and creates such excitement, but how does the sixth class lad feel when he’s left on the sideline while fourth and fifth class lads are on the team?

“He’s being clearly made aware that winning is the only thing that matters and he’s clearly not good enough. I can only imagine how that impacts his internal thought process.

“Another recent survey asked children whether they would like to lose as a player or win as a substitute? The vast majority chose losing as a player as their preferred option.

“That answer goes against the thinking of some coaches. They think the child is totally concerned about winning but that’s not the case.

“I hear people say that children are competitive and won’t enjoy games if scores aren’t kept. “Have they ever been at a birthday party when kids go out the back for a kick-about? There’s no scoreboard there but they spend hours up and down the garden after the ball.

“We cannot impose adult values on this. We have to be aware of what the child wants and what the core values of the GAA are.”

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice