Ten controversial decisions in Mayo sport

SPORT Daniel Carey looks back on ten decisions that made the headlines in Mayo over the last 60 years.

Ten controversial decisions

Feature

Daniel Carey

1 The premature whistle, 1948

THE 1948 All-Ireland final is remembered by many in Mayo as ‘the day the ref blew up early’.

In 1982, at the wedding of a Kiltimagh woman and a Cavan native, the father of the bride recalled another big Mayo-Cavan gathering 34 years previously, when ‘the referee played three minutes short, Cavan won by a point, and even though we have Knock down here, he only died last year!’

Throw in a dispute about whether Cavan’s Mick Higgins was standing too close when he blocked PΡdraic Carney’s late free, and you have a recipe for a long-running dispute.

2 Dan O’Neill joins Louth, 1956

CASTLEBAR native Dan O’Neill won an All-Ireland football title with Louth in 1957, just 18 months after leaving Mayo in controversial circumstances. A disagreement over expenses was the catalyst for his move to the Wee County, where he was stationed as a Garda.

O’Neill (who detailed the events in his book, Divided Loyalties) felt Mayo County Board were ‘penny-pinching’ when they failed to cover the full amount he requested to travel west to play with Mayo one weekend early in 1956. Feeling his credibility had been called into question, O’Neill took the monumental decision to switch.

3 The delayed whistle, 1966

‘MAYO robbed by overtime score’ screamed the back page of The Mayo News. This was the headline over Damian McHugh’s account of the 1966 Connacht final, in which Mayo lost by a point to the Galway side that went on to win three in a row.

Nowadays, injury time is part of the game, but the fact that Liam Sammon’s winner ‘was scored nearly two minutes after the duration of the hour’ was a major talking point. Mayo GAA Board Chairman Fr Leo Morahan acknowledged ‘the frankness of the official who … admitted the error which proved all-important’.

4 McHale’s sending-off, 1996

“THIRTEEN years on,” SeΡn Rice wrote in these pages last August, “and the name McEneaney is a metaphor in Mayo for grievance.” The McEneaney in question is Pat, who dismissed Liam McHale and Colm Coyle after the 1996 All-Ireland final replay rumpus.

The Monaghan official planned to send off McHale and Meath’s John McDermott, but an umpire said Coyle had to go because he was ‘after dropping about six of them’. Another umpire worked as a door-man in Carrickmacross, and was regularly asked by Meath revellers thereafter: ‘What did Coyle do?’ He would then recreate the punching motion and repeat the advice given to McEneaney.

5 Achill Rovers’ omission, 1999

BEING the best soccer team in the county wasn’t enough to allow Achill Rovers enter the Super League in 1999. The 1998 league champions used the local community centre as dressing-rooms, and thus their facilities didn’t meet the criteria drawn up for the new top flight.

“That was a disaster for us,” manager Patrick Francis Gallagher told The Mayo News 20 years on. “I think it actually set us back years, because we had a very young team [but] they were so disgusted, some of them packed up playing soccer. It took the heart out of the club.”

6 Mayo ladies’ kit row, 2003-4

“A WEXFORD supporter ran across Croke Park naked and got fined €100 in a court of law. Mayo ladies, who had all their clothes on, got fined €22,000.” So said Seamus Murray, Chairman of Mayo Ladies Supporters’ Club after the county’s 2003 All-Ireland title came with a sting in the tail.

This unprecedented punishment was for wearing Azzurri gear in contravention of a national agreement with O’Neills. There was mediation, a vote of no confidence in the executive, a reduced fine, and (briefly) a suspension ‘from all activities of the Association’ for Mayo before the row was resolved.

7 Coyle’s dream crushed, 2004

“WHAT team was ever picked by secret ballot?” Gerry Coyle asked after his son Henry was denied the chance to compete in the final Olympic Games qualifier in 2004.

As national welterweight champion, the Geesala boxer had seemingly earned the right to have a last cut at Athens, but with the High Performance team recommending that James Moore be sent in his stead, things were not so clear-cut.

“They wrecked my dream of going to the Olympics yet they haven’t the guts to stand up and be counted,” said Coyle after the Central Council vote sealed his fate.

8 Mickey Moran’s departure, 2006

IN his first season as manager, the Derryman took Mayo to a Connacht title and an All-Ireland final, but things went spectacularly wrong thereafter.

Critical comments were made at a County Board meeting, Moran’s right-hand man John Morrison resigned, and then on a Tuesday night in Sligo, Mickey and the County Board parted ways and the ‘family’ broke up.

So what happened? Only a handful of people know, and so far, nobody’s talked. It looks like we’ll have to wait for Moran’s memoirs – or maybe former County Board PRO Noelle Horan will reveal all some day?

9 Rugby relegation mess, 2008

WITH one game left in the 2008 Connacht Junior Rugby League, Sligo appeared safe on 16 points. OLBC, on 11 points, hoped to avoid relegation, while Tuam were in serious trouble on nine.

The remaining fixture had Tuam hosting Sligo, but the north-westerners decided not to travel and conceded the match. Big mistake. Teams who didn’t field were deducted five points. With Tuam being awarded five, this left Sligo joint bottom – and relegated, since they had lost their head-to-head with OLBC.

With legal action threatened, an Irish solution to this Irish problem was found. All three sides stayed up.

10 Castlebar Celtic ‘robbed’, 2008

“EVEN a couple of Rathkeale supporters said to me coming out: ‘Ye were robbed, lads’.” That’s what Declan Kilkelly told The Mayo News after his Castlebar Celtic side went down 2-1 to a Limerick side in the 2008-9 FAI Junior Cup.

Branding the officiating ‘disgraceful’, Kilkelly said Rathkeale’s equaliser was ‘embarrassingly offside’. Peter Dravins had what he called ‘a perfectly good goal’ ruled out in the closing stages, prompting protests that saw the Celtic boss sent to the stand. “If it’s [a] marginal [decision], you’ll swallow it,” he explained. “But when there are yards involved, then it’s cheating.”

Have your say

Disagree with our selection? Then tell us whose controversial decision should be included instead, justifying your choice in no more than 100 words.

Write to: Ten Moments In Time, Sports Department, The Mayo News, Westport, Co Mayo or e-mail [email protected].

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice