Selection headaches for Declan Kidney

RUGBY It’s been a long time since Ireland had such selection difficulties going into a Six Nations, writes Trevor Watson.

Headaches for Kidney

CrashBall

Trevor Watson

IT’S been a long time since Ireland had such selection difficulties going into a Six Nations Championship. And while it is obviously a good problem to have, Declan Kidney’s management skill are now about to be tested possibly more than ever before.

There are definitely five and possibly six positions which aren’t set in stone. How Kidney finds, and more importantly maintains, that balance for the Italy match and beyond is of immense importance.

Does he go with rookie Cian Healy or stick with the tried and trusted Marcus Horan at loose head? Or what about Tom Court, who is currently demolishing all in front him at scrum time? Court’s ability to play both sides is an invaluable asset, and that should see him get the nod on the bench ahead of Horan, with Healy getting the number one shirt.

Flannery will probably start as hooker, with Rory Best on the bench (which is a little unlucky on the ever-improving SeΡn Cronin, but he is still very young).

Jerseys three, four and five are sacrosanct, but it will be interesting to see if he tinkers with the back row with Shane Jennings, SeΡn O’Brien and Ulster’s Chris Henry all in flying form.

One would expect that Kidney will stick with his favoured trio of Ferris, Wallace and Heaslip, but the spot on the bench is 100 per cent up for grabs.

O’Leary looks to have no real threat for the scrum-half berth, but again it will be interesting to see who gets the bench slot. There’s not much to choose between Stringer, Reddan and Boss. They might opt for Stringer for the speedier pass, but his lack of game-time could hamper him.

The real debate is surrounding the number ten jersey – the old war chief O’Gara versus the young brave Sexton. It is a thoroughly exciting situation to be in. Oh, what Martin Johnson would do to have either in his ranks!

If the first trip was an away match in Paris, one would expect that O’Gara would get the nod, but if you want to give a rookie some game time, surely Italy at home (without their talismanic captain) is an ideal opportunity. Watch this space. Kidney is not afraid to make bold selections. Just ask Peter Stringer.

Paddy Wallace has done nothing wrong but D’arcy must get the nod to partner O’Driscoll in midfield. He has been in scintillating form for Leinster of late, and looks to be ahead of Wallace now in the pecking order.

Bowe and Kearney will occupy two of the back three slots, but Luke Fitzgerald is a huge loss. It is a conundrum as to who will replace him. Shane Horgan has re-discovered his form of late and Andrew Trimble has been in flying form for Ulster. Keith Earls can also play on the wing, and if he doesn’t start, he is almost certainly sure to make the squad with his ability to cover virtually any jersey from 12 out.

It is exciting times for Kidney and his charges. This is what we think he will select next weekend: Kearney, Bowe, O’Driscoll, D’arcy, Earls, O’Gara, O’Leary. Heaslip, Wallace, Ferris, O’Connell and O’Callaghan, Hayes, Flannery and Healy.

A no-brainer at openside

WE are steadily getting through our greatest ever XV and this week, it really is a no-brainer for the openside flanker jersey. The list of nominees is endless, Burger, Betson, Back, Smith, Kronfeld but it in the end there is only one. He was once described as Josh Kronfeld, Michael Jones and Zinzan Brooke all rolled into one. Richie McCaw.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice