Learning to adapt

We look at the Mayo minors of 1999 and ask: where are they now?placeholder image
We look at the Mayo minors of 1999 and ask: where are they now?

GAA Mayo referee Vincent Neary has had first-hand experience of applying the experimental rules. We get the views of the Bonniconlon official ahead of next weekend’s GAA Congress.

Learning to adapt

Daniel Carey

NEXT weekend, the GAA Congress will decide whether to keep the experimental rules which have been used on a trial basis for the January competitions and National Leagues. The new regulations, which have seen players leave the field of play and replaced by a substitute if they commit a ‘highly disruptive’ foul, need the support of a two-thirds majority in Cork next weekend if they’re to be introduced on a permanent basis.

Mayo referee Vincent Neary has had first-hand experience of applying the experimental rules. The long-serving inter-county official has taken charge of a number of games in the FBD League and National Football League, and likes what he sees so far.

“After an initial warming-up process, I think they have bedded in well,” he told The Mayo News. “Okay, in the first round or two [of the league] or even in the FBD [League], it wouldn’t be easy to gauge how they were going, because [referees] were tentative in their application. They didn’t want to ruin games, and they didn’t want to shirk their responsibilities either.”

Neary pays tribute to the ‘huge time, resources and energy’ which the GAA have invested in marketing the new rules. Advertisements have been taken out in match programmes, while GAA Head of Games Pat Daly and Disciplinary Task Force chairman Liam O’Neill have ‘spared nothing’ in their efforts to educate supporters, players, managers and referees.

Neary notes that Daly and O’Neill have briefed referees regularly, using footage from recent games at meetings with officials to illustrate how the new rules should work in practice. They even went so far as to get ‘little voting machines’, and both referees and managers were asked to instantly vote on whether the clips they’re being shown are punishable by black, yellow or red cards, or merely frees.

While there was only ‘a very slight difference’ between referees, managers’ responses to what they were shown ranged from ‘no free at all’ to a sending-off. Still, the men in black are the ones in the firing line. Is it a difficult balancing act for referees to get right in the early part of the year?

“Well, you’re going into whole new territory, and you don’t want to be woefully dramatic on the first day,” notes Neary. “People have to get a feel for the rules, and players, in fairness, have to get a feel for them as well. But you look at statistics, you will plainly see that there are more scores, there’s more playing time … [every indicator] goes in favour of them. And yet, the physicality isn’t gone out of it. You can still have fair hits and fair shoulders, well within the rules.”

But the Bonniconlon man has noted a change in behaviour among players in recent months – “Rather than dive in and prevent a score no matter what the consequences,” he notes, “players are inclined nearly to stand back when a forward is running at them … in fairness, they needed time to learn, and managers needed time to learn too. Because they’re not awfully worried about the application of rules – they want to win, and that’s what they’re there for. Referees are there for a different reason – they don’t care whether it’s Armagh or Monaghan that win!”

Neary, who also acts as Assistant Secretary of Mayo GAA Board as well Secretary of both the North Mayo Board and Bord na nÓg, says the rules haven’t caused him any particular difficulties – ‘like every other call, it’s just how you see it in a split-second’, he says.

“In the month of February on perishing cold days, there might be sleet or driving rain, it’s how you see it – and you don’t have the benefit of Sky Sports with 15 cameras looking down! The man in studio will never be able to call it as it instantly happens, but before the free is taken, he knows what should be done, because he’s seen all the replays!”

After an earlier attempt to change the rules faltered in the face of criticism from managers, there has clearly been a concerted effort on the part of the GAA to push the positives aspects of the changes. Neary is pleased that the rules have at least got ‘a fair rattle’ this time around, feels they have got the approval of most referees, and expects they will get the required two-thirds majority.

“But as always, it’s the rules we have to apply – and if there’s a whole new book of them given to us, that’s what we’re there for!” he says with a laugh. “Managers might have a different opinion [on the rules]. County secretaries might, county chairmen might – because they don’t care what happens if the result goes right! If our own county is playing and if an incident goes in your favour and you get a goal and you win an All-Ireland, you won’t say ‘boo’. If it’s the other way, you’ll be on about it for six months. That’s human nature.”

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice