‘Gaelic football is in crisis’, says ex-Mayo manager

placeholder image

FOOTBALL Former Dublin player and Mayo manager Brian McDonald says he fears for the future of Gaelic football.

‘Football is in crisis’

THE game’s popularity grows apace outside Ireland, but the apparent chasm into which Gaelic football is heading within the country is the cause of considerable concern.

Leading national commentators write of the wrong direction the game is taking, the bulking of players, the diminution of its traditional skills, and the legacy of some of its ugly features to future generations.

Former Dublin footballer Brian MacDonald, who also managed Mayo for a season in 1992, has joined the nascent chorus of criticism about the decline of the game’s old values and said he fears for the future of Gaelic football, how it is going and how the rules are being interpreted.

“I think football is in crisis,” he said, “And I can’t see they will solve it in this generation of footballers.”

Take the hand-pass ­— a rule that is not being executed legally, “When they go onto the pitch for a warm-up you can see players throwing the ball to one another. Kerry are past masters at it. I saw Cork get a goal the other day from a pass thrown to him by a colleague.”

Players, he said, should be made observe the rule; one hand static, the other striking the ball.

Emphasis nowadays seems to be on making giants of young players. The bigger the footballer, he said, the more likely he was to play for the county. Ordinary average size fellows struggled for recognition on county sides.

Is the problem, he wondered, rooted in qualified people out of colleges unduly influencing training methods? “They certainly are qualified to do the training, but some, I fear, have no real idea about the skills of the game.”

MacDonald’s is an interesting voice on the theme. The holder of a Celtic cross, two All-Ireland minor medals and a junior with Dublin, his is an authentic voice on the current drift of Gaelic football.

He came to Castlebar with a finance company in the sixties, married Mary Harney (no not that one) and settled. There he added to his roll of honour a Connacht junior medal with Mayo and a brace of county senior medals with the local Mitchels.

He’s no devotee of the local press, but peel back the layers of myth and perception, and the pent-up ire of old antagonisms, and you are faced with the forthright views of a knowledgeable football mind.

Another ugly development, he said, is the flailing of an opponent with the arms, the abolition of which will be hardest to implement. “There is no reason why you should put your arm or hand on an opponent who has the ball. In our day you were allowed to block down and to shoulder him. You were not allowed to flail an opponent. To get that out of Gaelic football will take a huge effort.”

Recently he saw two fellows trying to punch the ball from another player’s hand. They were practising what used to be a foul.

Living in Roscommon in the fifties, Brian MacDonald was a sub on the county minor team of 1956. Leitrim beat them in the Connacht final and went on to play Dublin in the All-Ireland final . . . a little known fact about Leitrim football. He was a minor again in 1957 before returning to the county of his birth, to commence his medal collection.

In general, the ball was much faster then. “All the time the ball was going forward. The type of game that is being played now was reserved for 7-a-side football where you held onto possession and you dilly-dallied around.”

Nor were they allowed charge with the ball into an opponent. It was a free against you. “The norm now seems to be to get the ball and bulldoze your way through.”

Football was tough then. “The third man tackle was in force which protected the man getting the ball. Sometimes it did not protect the man going in to tackle him, because the other fellow took him out.”

But the game was more free-flowing, and there was greater emphasis on skill than there is now. Work with the ball nowadays was mostly short distance stuff. In his day it was thirty yards, get into position and put it over the bar.

“I’m not sure where the game is going now, but it’s not going to be nice,” he said.

He said Mayo have had teams capable of winning two or three All-Irelands. Why they didn’t was difficult to fathom. James Horan was very unlucky. He put an awful lot into it and did a wonderful job, and he didn’t get the break of the ball. John Maughan also did a very good job. “I would not fault any of those fellows. They all did what they had to do. They tried so hard.”

He is glad Congress turned down the introduction of the hooter/clock. In a league final in New York the GAA were experimenting with the Bogue clock and Dublin, a point behind, were awarded a free in the last minute in front of the goal. “A row broke out, the ball was kicked up the field, the hooter sounded, the match was over . . . and it cost me a national league medal,” he said.

Mayo playing for pride in Cork

AFTER Dublin, what next?

A trip to Cork on Sunday for more of the same, for further evidence that the Mayo that has charmed us those past four years, the Mayo to which we have lost our hearts, is no longer that Mayo?

A fading Mayo is perhaps inevitable. Slippage after so much disappointment is understandable.

But surely neither is this truly the Mayo that plumbed the depths of disappointment in MacHale Park, the Mayo that seemed tethered to old failures, old intrinsic inconsistencies which we had begun to forget.

After Dublin, Cork seems equally daunting, their march to the top founded mainly on the basic skill of accuracy. Points from distance, which were once the raw material of every successful side, have become so rare in Mayo that we revel in the occasional one as if it were a marvellous achievement.

Cork have not forsaken that old principle. Their accuracy from all angles has devastated opponents since the start of the season. Points within a radius of 45 metres are the norm.

Colm O’Neill personifies those qualities.

He unlocked the gates of Tyrone’s cover in Omagh with prodigious marksmanship that, according to manager Brian Cuthbert, has been a feature of his game all season.

He’s not alone in Cork’s resurgence. Brian Hurley is equally lethal around the goal and the influence of guys like Fintan Gould and Donncha O’Connor is significant.

Can Mayo burn the traces?  A lot of thinking is required on the sideline as well as on the field. Dublin drained the life out of them and the first essential on Sunday is, win or lose, to get back some pride, to renew self-belief.

Since Donal Vaughan left, the backline is less durable, and opinion is hardening among pundits that for all of his excellence up front, maybe Aidan O’Shea could be even more fruitfully employed at centre-back.

Without the injured Cillian O’Connor spearheading the attack on Sunday, however, the selectors have little choice but to persist with the younger O’Shea as their key to scores.

Elsewhere, little change in personnel is expected and while Mayo have rebounded from difficult positions in the past, a positive return from Sunday’s game will require a performance even more grinding than characterised their win in Derry.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice