COLUMN: There should’ve been standards over impressions at All-Star’s


There was a lot of discussion on social media relating to the interviews that occurred at the All-Star’s event
Jeremy Clarkson gave one of the best interviews of the Formula One season in Austin. The former Top Gear and Grand Tour star was speaking with Martin Brundle and the Sky Sports team when the talk turned to Brundle’s chat with Kim Kardashian on the grid in Singapore. Had Clarkson seen it?
He hadn’t, and he had no interest in seeing it. “Why would I be interested in Kim Kardashian?” he asked. “I’m here to watch Formula 1, not Kim Kardashian.” Blunt, the way only Clarkson does it. I laughed, because he said what plenty of F1 fans were thinking. Clarkson didn’t come down in the last shower and he knew the audience he was playing to of course, but it got me thinking.
THE GRID WALK
Formula one has ridden the influencer wave harder than most sports. Since Netflix released Drive to Survive in 2019, every influencer and Tom, Dick and Harry seems to want a grid pass. Fast cars, billionaires, yachts and glamour. For social media content, it’s rocket fuel. Brundle’s grid walk interviews have become viral sensations. Minutes before the lights go out, the former driver walks the grid live with an open microphone and doorsteps whatever superstar, willing or unwilling, he sees.
As per F1 T&Cs, if you are on the grid you are game to talk. Some encounters are gems. Colin Farrell stopped for him in Miami and talked about his first Grand Prix, at Monza in 1998, on a budget trip with two friends. “I love this, it’s mega to be here,” he said. The clip flew around the internet because of the passion in every word, likewise Irish actor Liam Cunningham.
Others walk past with an entourage in tow and try to give Brundle the cold shoulder, but he is wonderfully persistent. He has been on record saying he hates the segment, but it makes for brilliant TV.
GAA’S GRID WALK MOMENT
The GAA had its own version at the All Stars recently. BPerfect Cosmetics were shooting TikTok content on the night, and one clip blew up for all the wrong reasons.
The interviewer seemed to have no grasp of the game and asked some ridiculous questions. It was embarrassing and unprofessional, and it did no service to the players, the night or the history of the Association. Part of me suspects the naivety was put on, because a clueless interview gets more views than a good one. Either way, she took a hammering online and, in some ways, I feel sorry for her.
I tweeted about how “This infiltration of influencers into sporting events has to be stopped. Looks as bad as the Galway Races.” The post passed 100,000 views. Clearly I’m not the only one who feels strongly about this. For me, the bigger responsibility lies with whoever arranged the access. BPerfect ran a similar series at last year’s All Stars so there is clearly a commercial angle to it. But whoever sends those invitations has a duty to make sure the game and the evening are treated with respect.
My fear is the personalities become the main event and the sport becomes a sideshow. Look at Galway. The racing and the history, the things that put the festival on the map, seem almost incidental now beside the who’s who of social media personalities and content gathering. The reaction online from traditional race-goers who feel likewise is always an interesting spectacle and of course it’s not a phenomenon only Galway face. It’s spreading everywhere.
A PUBLIC CHARADE
There is something about influencer culture itself that wrecks my head. Too much of it feels fake. Manufactured personalities, staged moments and supposedly perfect lives, all carefully arranged for public consumption. I believe it does more harm to society than good.
Sport, at its best, is the opposite of all that. Build whatever image you like, but eventually you have to go out and perform against somebody doing everything in their power to beat you and nobody fakes that.
The All Stars is supposed to recognise what those players have earned. That’s why I feel protective of it. When players become props for somebody else’s content, something worthwhile gets diminished.
BRANDING
One defence of the clip kept coming up. The GAA is too traditional and we don’t want to open the game to a new audience.
In my day job, I own a digital marketing business built on LinkedIn personal branding. My clients include tech CEOs in Silicon Valley and a billion-dollar fintech. Building brands and putting them in front of the right people is my bread and butter. I know influencer marketing works and there is serious money being made from it. But something being good marketing for BPerfect doesn’t make it good for the GAA.
BPerfect has built an audience around cosmetics. There will be some GAA people among its followers, but the game isn’t what brought them there. If the argument is this opens the GAA to a new audience, then show them something worth caring about. Instead, the talking point became an interviewer who hadn’t a clue about the game.
Awareness has value. But in my industry we have a name for impressions, views and reach with nothing behind them. Vanity metrics. They look great in a report but invisible in a balance sheet. My hunch is there will be few, if any, National League tickets sold off the back of TikTok content like this. Some in the corridors of power will defend it on commercial grounds. But for an organisation as proud as the GAA, not all publicity is good publicity. Standards matter more than a few euro and a few views.
Formula One is the example everyone points to. Look at how F1 did it. Drive to Survive told the sport’s own stories of the drivers, team bosses, rivalries, crashes and contracts. It gave people a reason to care about what happened on the track. It was so popular after season 1 that giants like Mercedes and Ferrari reversed their initial decision not to take part. The celebrities on the grid arrived after the growth.
There are GAA creators doing good work and I follow a few of them. They know the game and care about it and they should be first in the queue for opportunities like this. It was good to see some invited. And don’t give me the argument that the GAA is not inclusive.
RESPECT THE GAME
I’m uncomfortable with where influencer culture and sport are heading. Too often the sport becomes the backdrop and the people who earned their place there become supporting characters. The GAA turned 142 recently. It came a hell of a long way without influencers and it will continue to thrive without them too.