THE VERDICT: Outside voices predict the Mayo-Kerry All-Ireland final


Well-known faces from Dublin, Donegal, and Louth offered their opinions on Sunday’s big game in Croke Park
KEVIN MCMANAMON (Eight-time Dublin All-Ireland winner)
KERRY’S MAIN STRENGTH
Kerry’s sheer talent, experience, and talent they have. Mayo are in year one, and Kerry are probably in year seven or eight.
Their experience and resilience; they are not playing great and getting the wins, I think they're going to need to be smashed if they're going to be beaten at all.
MAYO’S MAIN STRENGTH
Mayo's ability to run the ball, and I like the mix between youth and experience. The good impact from the bench, but I just think it's their running power, particularly on counter attacks. It's great to see old-school man-to-man defending.
The zone defense worked for Dublin against Kerry, so it's going to be an interesting one. It’ll be a bit of a high-wire act if they go man-to-man everywhere against Kerry. I don't think it's going to work out for them great, but that man-to-man intensity tends to be their strength.
WHERE THE GAME WILL BE WON OR LOST
It's how Mayo defends. Watching them over this year and maybe playing against them over the years, they are very good at backup defense. How does Mayo defend against the big ones?
They have six of the best forwards in the country, so I think the matchups are going to be important. Number one, and then how the Mayo defenders support each other.
VERDICT: My head reckons that Kerry will win it by three or four, but I just have a feeling that this time around that Mayo might get it done.
EAMONN MCGEE (Donegal All-Ireland winner)
KERRY’S MAIN STRENGTH
The simple answer for Kerry is David Clifford.
When you have one of the greatest players to ever play in a game, with the talent he has and what he can do with the ball, that's just a massive aspect in and of itself.
MAYO’S MAIN STRENGTH
That young exuberance and energy Mayo have displayed in the last few games is going to be their strength.
None of them have that baggage. They're not coming into the fourth All-Ireland where they've lost. Eventually that Mayo group from last week got damaged and started to doubt themselves. This group don't.
WHERE THE GAME WILL BE WON OR LOST
A lot of it will come down to what Mayo can do to stop Clifford. Do you do what Donegal do and go after the supply to him?
Or do you go the Dublin route where you have a marker on him and get an extra man in there when you’re defending? Either way, it’ll be interesting.
VERDICT: Kerry
PETER FITZPATRICK (Former Louth manager)
KERRY’S MAIN STRENGTH
Kerry's main strength is Paudie and David Clifford. They're probably the top two players in the country at the moment.
Paudie is the creator and the playmaker, and even last week against Dublin, when you think Dublin's going to go on to win the game, all of a sudden David does something miraculous, and he's an absolutely fantastic individual.
MAYO’S MAIN STRENGTH
The full forward line. I think Beirne, O’Donohoe, and Kobe are fantastic. Mayo caught Louth on the hop. They kept the ball moving the whole time and kept attacking, attacking, attacking. This is probably the best Mayo team they have had in a long, long time.
I think you've got a fantastic, well-balanced team. Mayo has an absolutely fantastic chance of winning the Sam Maguire. I think this is probably their best opportunity.
WHERE THE GAME WILL BE WON OR LOST
Mayo are going to have to sacrifice two players. Someone's going to have to follow Paudie absolutely everywhere. Every time Kerry gets the ball, they're going to be looking for David Clifford the whole time, and the playmaker there is Paudie.
The person who's going to mark David Clifford should set himself the target that he's going to score a maximum of four or five points because there’s no point going out, and thinking that you're going to keep David Clifford scoreless. If you can keep him down to four or five, the person I think marking has done an absolutely fantastic job.
VERDICT: If you look at the last two games, Kerry could have been beaten. There's a hunger this year in Mayo that they never had before. My heart and my head is telling me that I think Mayo's going to win.
KEVIN O’NEILL (Former Mayo captain)
KERRY’S MAIN STRENGTH
Kerry have a once-in-a-generation player in David Clifford, a few other elite starting forwards and other high-impact forwards who are on the subs bench that they can bring on when the game is in the final quarter.
On top of that, Kerry possess a big-game DNA & “know what it takes” to win pedigree - this is their fourth final in five years, they are chasing a league-and-championship double that they haven't managed since 2006-07
MAYO’S MAIN STRENGTH
Our forwards - who are told to express themselves and not be afraid to make mistakes - are a key strength. They have the pace, the skill, and they are not afraid to try for two pointers or to shoot for goal. They've been improving with every game.
Our “asymmetric” football style is also vital. Mayo will need to bring more chaos and high-tempo football all over the pitch.
These unconventional tactics have stood us well in the last two games. Against highly structured Division One Teams like Kerry, Donegal, and Armagh, this can have a huge impact. The chaos throws other teams off, but it requires 70 + minutes of high intensity.
It is very hard to keep this level of intensity up. The great All-Ireland-winning Tyrone Teams brought an unconventional approach to Kerry, and the rest is history.
We also can leverage our own big game experience with players and management who have all gone through All-Ireland Final day before and they know the pitfalls, what works and does not work and how to approach it mentally - a fast start is critical, winning the throw in, winning the first ball, physically “fronting up” in your face individual battles sets the tonne early in the game.
WHERE THE GAME WILL BE WON OR LOST
Whether Mayo's defense can hold up against Kerry's firepower for a full 70+ minutes including managing the Kerry impact subs who will come on later in the game
Also, can we stop enough of the quality supply of ball going into David Clifford from out the field - locking down the axis of Paudie Clifford, Joe O’Connor & Gavin White will be key here and not allowing them to settle on the ball which allows them seconds to pick out key passes to the inside line.
VERDICT: Kerry go in as huge favorites and have the edge in squad depth, proven All Ireland winning experience, and in David Clifford that once-in-a-generation star.
I'd lean on Kerry to win — though with Mayo's inside line, it could be closer than the pundits' odds suggest and a huge opportunity and potential for a Mayo win if we can get it right!
CORA STAUNTON (Mayo LGFA All-Ireland winner)
KERRY’S MAIN STRENGTH
The Cliffords - Paudie and David. I think they're obviously their main strengths. David obviously inside for scoring, but Paudie in general. Kerry’s attacking unit is very very strong around the middle eight.
In terms of David, Paudie, Seanie O'Shea, Diarmuid O'Connor, Joe O'Connor, that kind of middle eight section is very strong. If you get enough possession to that forward line, they're very, very hard to stop.
MAYO’S MAIN STRENGTH
Mayo’s inside line is definitely where their strength lies-the three boys inside. I don't like to call it a full forward line anymore. Their top three is very strong.
But add in the likes of Tommy Conroy and Cian McHale to make it a top five, with Ryan moving out to center forward and one of the boys coming off. That's where we have our main strengths at the moment to be our inside line in the forward line.
But I'd like to call it a top five rather than a top three because I think what we've come off the benches is strong as well.
WHERE THE GAME WILL BE WON OR LOST
Which team can win enough possession around the midfield. Not just kickouts but also who can get on top of the breaking ball, and then who can get enough possession to forward line in both teams.
But I also think both the Kerry goalkeeper Shane Ryan and Jack Livingstone will have a big say in how the game is going to pan out. Ryan has been excellent for carrying his kickouts, and can Jack get to that level? He's done very well.
Probably a little bit more of a conservative kickout where we do probably the same things nine out of ten times, whereas Kerry's kickouts are a little bit more expansive and they change them up. I think if you're to dig a little bit deeper, that's where it could be decisive.
VERDICT: It's very hard to call. I'll call it a draw.
