Donegal rematch a timely reminder
FOOTBALL Nothing gets supporters talking quite like team selections. John O’Mahony’s recent team selections have been as analysed as any in his illustrious management career.
Donegal rematch a timely reminder
Next weekend’s trip to Letterkenny is a big test
Overview
Mike Finnerty
THERE’S nothing that gets supporters talking quite like team selections. There is speculation before the team is announced, contemplation when it is made public, and the result usually dictates the post-mortems.
John O’Mahony’s recent team selections have been as analysed as any in his long and illustrious management career. Seasoned observers and fresh-faced football-watchers are looking for signs; of consistency, strategy and, most importantly, progress.
The team that O’Mahony, Kieran Gallagher and Tommy Lyons pick for next weekend will probably be very similar to the one that took to the field against Derry last time out. But the result is, arguably, much more important.
Next Saturday will be almost two years to the day since John O’Mahony took his Mayo team to McCumhaill Park in Ballybofey for a National League match against Donegal.
He had only been back in the Mayo hotseat for four months and used the second game of that National League schedule to mix something old with something new in an effort to put his stamp on Team Mayo.
Ballaghaderreen midfielder James Kilcullen started for the second successive game at full-back while Billy Joe Padden was handed the number six shirt after a solid display there on the opening day against Kerry. David Brady, starting his tenth NFL campaign, partnered Pat Harte at midfield, Trevor Mortimer was on the ‘40’ and Austin O’Malley got the nod at full-forward. The Mayo captain was Kevin O’Neill.
Now fast forward 24 months. Next weekend, Mayo head back up the N4 in search of two crucial league points after an opening day defeat to Derry and it seems somehow appropriate that it is Donegal waiting to ask the hard questions again.
They snatched victory in the corresponding fixture last year in Castlebar with a late goal, won their first ever NFL title against Mayo in April 2007 at Croke Park, and were also three points too good for us in that match in Ballybofey two years ago. The recent history between the two teams has not been kind to Mayo.
A cursory glance at the squad that will tog out against Donegal next weekend also makes interesting reading. Nine players who featured on Mayo’s last trip to Ballybofey are not in John O’Mahony’s panel these days: James Kilcullen, Keith Higgins, David Heaney, David Brady, Kevin O’Neill, James Nallen, Marty McNicholas, Ger Brady and Aidan Campbell.
However, seven of the team that started in February 2007 also started against Derry ten days ago: David Clarke, Liam O’Malley, Billy Joe Padden, Peadar Gardiner, Andy Moran, Trevor Mortimer and Alan Dillon. Another three that were involved two years ago (Conor Mortimer, Pat Harte and Mark Ronaldson) also came on in Ballina.
The only player who saw action against Donegal two years ago and was an unused substitute against Derry last week was Austin O’Malley.
Depending on your perspective, the comparative analysis above suggests one of two things: (1) Mayo are finally heading in the right direction with the introduction of some young talent like Donal Vaughan, Kevin McLoughlin, Ger Cafferkey, Trevor Howley and Tom Parsons; or (2) that very little has changed in the space of two seasons and a lack of leaders, in almost every line, remains a serious issue.
It also seems likely that Keith Higgins, James Nallen and David Heaney will be back in harness by the time Mayo fly to New York on May 7 so most of the 15-20 players used against either Leitrim or Roscommon on June 20 should be survivors from previous campaigns.
Who will take their opportunity next Saturday afternoon? Do this current Mayo squad have enough quality in the key positions to turn Donegal over for the first time since a two-point win down in Ballina four years ago? And who will show the kind of leadership that every team needs to win away at a place like O’Donnell Park, Letterkenny?
We will know much more by 4pm on Valentine’s Day.