Ciaran McDonald on Best Mayo Team Since 1960
FOOTBALL Ciaran McDonald edges out Conor Mortimer for the first corner forward slot on SeΡn Rice’s Best Mayo Team Since 1960.
Lucky thirteen for McDonald
Sean Rice
BEFORE he stumbled badly last Saturday I had begun to question whether there had been a better Mayo corner forward than the man who has been holding down the position over the past eight years. Has there been anyone better than Conor Mortimer over the past fifty years?
Anyone but Mortimer, I hear. And selection for the No 13 jersey on my best team of the past fifty years looms inopportunely for the Shrule/Glencorrib man following a nightmare performance against Sligo.
But rummaging through the archives of memory for a genuine challenger to Mortimer leaves you wondering who is better entitled to selection.
There is no shortage of contenders, 109 in all. Among them is the resourceful Johnny Farragher whose name springs up for many positions, and I find it difficult to dismiss the sharp edge of commitment he brought to his game.
Around the same time Ballina’s John Nealon prowled hungrily around the edge of the square. In his 45 appearances for Mayo he scored 14 goals and 16 points, but was noted more for his contribution to the scores of others.
Nealon’s input was never fully appreciated until he was dropped for the Connacht final of 1969 . . . after scoring four goals in the semi-final against Leitrim. He was restored for the replay of the final against Galway and bagged 1-1.
Willie McGee, although more popular as a full-forward, lined out in the corner on a few occasions. So did Billy Fitzpatrick, Michael Fitzmaurice, Ray Dempsey, Brian Kilkelly, Kevin O’Neill, Tom Byrne, P.J. King, Frank McDonald, M.J. Ruddy, Maurice Sheridan and a hundred others.
One of those was Ciaran McDonald, also of recent vintage. Controversial, moody and brilliant, he nevertheless failed to fulfill for Mayo the enormous potential his left foot had promised.
A variety of great scores was registered by that inspired foot, and from it all sorts of deliveries were executed . . . long, short, medium, sublime and preposterous. With uncanny accuracy he could thread a pass to a colleague half the field away. More than anyone he had the capacity to excel on any of the best teams in the country.
Unfortunately, speculation too often centred on his mood swings, not on how he might perform, but whether or not he would turn up. Frustrated managers went out of their way to appease his whims . . . but in the end the inscrutable Crossmolina man became entangled in the web of his own paradox. And Mayo never fully benefited from an enormous talent.
Mortimer’s career has not been without some quirks. His flamboyance hasn’t always endeared himself to managers or audiences. But through thick and thin he has held that corner position for nearly a decade . . . because no one can take it from him.
His performance on Saturday will have blighted the memory of better days . . . and it may be an indication that the gloss is at last beginning to fade. But Mortimer has a habit of bouncing back to confound his critics, and may do so again.
In the meantime, a man who is second only to Joe Corcoran as Mayo’s leading scorer of all time with 14 goals and 329 points to his credit, cannot be readily discarded.
Inevitably, it boils down to a choice between him and McDonald for that corner position. And when you peel away all the peculiarities of the Crossmolina ace, all his frustrating behaviour, you are still left with a talent, however underused, that comes along only once or twice in a lifetime. For that reason he edges out Conor Mortimer.
To McDonald, thus, goes the No 13 jersey.
The team so far
1. Eugene Lavin; 2. Willie Casey, 3. Ray Prendergast, 4. Dermot Flanagan;
5. Ger Feeney, 6. John Morley,
7. James Nallen; 8. WJ Padden, 9. TJ Kilgallon;
10. Martin Carney, 11. Liam McHale, 12. Joe Corcoran; 13. Ciaran McDonald.