‘Valerie's Law' moves closer to reality as Cabinet prepares to sign off on it

placeholder image

Law is named in honour of Valerie French, who was murdered by her husband James Kilroy near Westport nearly seven years

Legislation that would give courts the power to remove or limit the guardianship rights of a parent convicted of killing their partner is poised to receive Cabinet approval tomorrow (Wednesday) morning, marking a landmark moment for those who have campaigned tirelessly for the change.

The Bill takes its name from Valerie French, the mother who was killed by her husband James Kilroy in 2019 outside their home in Kilbree, Co Mayo. She was 41 at the time of her death.

Kilroy was found guilty of her murder on July 26th, 2024 and received a mandatory life sentence. Despite the conviction, he remains a legal guardian of the couple's children — a situation her brother David French has been campaigning to change.

The Guardianship of Infants (Amendment) Bill 2026 will be brought before Cabinet tomorrow morning by the Minister for Justice, Jim O'Callaghan, with the legislation anticipated to become law by the end of the year.

Speaking at the GRA Conference in Westport last month, Minister O'Callaghan described the legislation as "an important piece of legislation" and paid tribute to David French for being "such a strong advocate for it."

The Bill does not provide for the automatic removal of guardianship rights. Courts will be required to assess whether a parent has failed in their duty and whether making such an order is in the best interests of the child.

'Killing a mother is child abuse'

David French, who has driven the campaign for the legislation, welcomed the Cabinet approval but cautioned that much work remains ahead.

"This is great — it's great to see it, I super welcome it, but it's not the end of it," he told The Mayo News. "This is the start of a process of putting it through the Dáil and having it debated by our representatives, and then, if it goes through the Dáil, to have it done through the Seanad and then signed off by the President. So there's a long process."

French described the current legal situation as a glaring gap. "This is a very obvious loophole in the law which means that killers retain their guardianship of shared children despite conviction. The idea of Valerie's Law is to make life simpler for everyone, including Tusla, by suspending guardianship of a killer at least when there's a verdict, and recognise the fact that killing a mother is child abuse."

He also stressed the importance of getting the legislation right, even if it takes time. "Even if it took another couple of years, it has to be absolutely watertight, it has to stand up. There are people who will challenge it. There's no point making something and then having it fall at the first hurdle."

A Legal Anomaly

Mayo solicitor working in Family Law, Hilary O'Connor, of JV Gearys in Castlebar explained the constitutional complexity underpinning the issue. Under Article 41 of the Irish Constitution, she noted, the state recognises the married family as "the primary and fundamental unit group" of society — a provision that has historically made it difficult to interfere with the rights of a married parent.

"The difficulty here for the French family is that one of those parties, Mr. Kilroy, killed the other, Valerie, and therefore he is then the only custodian and guardian of these children and all of the rights that flow from that," she said. "These children really are in a kind of legal no man's land."

O'Connor described the current situation as "an anomaly" and said it was "not fair and not right" that the children's uncertain legal position was a direct consequence of their father killing their mother.

David French said the disconnect between the criminal courts and other legal forums had struck him as particularly jarring throughout the process. "A verdict in the criminal court — our experience is that it might as well happen on the moon as far as family law or property law, or any other venue is concerned," he said. "Murder is absolutely massive, unless it happens in your family. You don't realise what a massive, massive thing it is, and it seems to have no implications outside the criminal court — up until now."

Timeline

The road to Cabinet approval has been years in the making. Holly Cairns TD of the Social Democrats first began work on a private member's bill in July 2024, which was subsequently introduced to the Dáil by Gary Gannon TD in April 2025. The legislation received cross-party support, with numerous TDs and Senators raising the issue in the Dáil throughout 2025.

At a European level, Kathleen Funchion MEP formally called for the implementation of Valerie's Law in the European Parliament in Strasbourg in February 2025. The following April, EU Commissioner for Justice Michael McGrath hosted a meeting with David French and Funchion in Brussels to discuss guardianship laws and children's rights across the EU.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice