Survival – Irish traditional music and song

Westport’s thorny Garden of Edenplaceholder image
Westport’s thorny Garden of Eden

In this celebration of Seachtain na Gaeilge it is fair to state: ‘Ní bheidh a leithéid ann arís.’ He is none other than Séamus Duffy.

Survival – Irish traditional music and song in print

DeFacto

His work is timely as one of the last, if not the last, surviving members of Comhaltas since it was founded in 1951. Its eight chapters are titled Beginnings, The Music, Musical Instruments, Singing, Fading Fortunes, The Green Fields of America, Comhaltas Ceóltoirí Éireann, and The Constitution. The book oozes with knowledge and facts. It is a treasure trove of information. 

Séamus lauds the gramophones and vinyl records brought back from America in the 1920s and ‘30s. These re-introduced to the Irish the masters of music who had emigrated. He cites the music of Coleman, Morrison, McKenna, Killoran, Tuohy and Paddy Sweeney holding him and his three brothers and three sisters spellbound ‘as jig followed reel and hornpipe followed jig till the sun went down in a blaze of glory behind the Nephin mountain and it was time for us children to go to bed and the land of dreams’.

There was no formal education in traditional music for the most part back then. Everything was ‘passed down from father to son, mother to daughter, from one family member to another’. He describes the qualities and characteristics embodied in traditional music – melody, pathos, cuts, stops and aesthetics. There are variations, phrasing, rhythms and tempos in music that was always in demand since dancing was a popular pastime. 

For Séamus, the greatest musical instrument is the voice. Traditional singing has no accompaniment, unlike folk singing. The book is peppered with fine examples of songs, many of them from Séamus’ pen. He laments that ‘no serious attempt at scientific investigation of Irish traditional songs has been made to date …’.

He quotes PH Pearse: “The magic of the ballad lies in the simplicity of its language and the beauty of the thoughts it contains.” He adds that a good traditional ballad was the most articulate heart cry of a people. A good song demands attention to detail and universality. Love and unrequited love dominate. The use of place-names is common. Invocation of the muses, local history, satire and subversive themes are also used. “Let it be categorically stated, however, that ballads in English cannot compare with amhráin i nGaeilge where the words are totally absorbed by the melody and the voice is taxed to the uttermost.” A good ballad must have a ‘meaty theme and a virile narrative’ with an exposition, body and climax or conclusion, aided and abetted by ornamentation, all expressed in a regional style. Ornamentation is ‘the art of building clusters of tiny notes around certain notes in the basic melodic line of a song with a view to adding variety and sweetness to that particular line of the melody. It is usually done on the liquid consonants L, M and N by a natural traditional singer.’

The harp, its origin and history come alive along with harpers. The pipes, first used in warfare in Ireland by Rory O’Moore in the 1641 Rebellion, and their birth as uilleann pipes is explored. The fiddle, flute and tin whistle and their gifted exponents are examined. The pantheon abounds – O’Carolan, Bunting, Galligan, Flanagan, Tansey, etc. The history of the melodeon (the musical instrument of choice for Mayo people with their unique style), is recalled and its morphing into the accordion, while the concertina found a home in Clare. Some instruments do not make the grade. He cites the use of stringed instruments in the playing of Irish traditional music – mandolins, mandocello, basouki, cittern, tenor banjo, and banjo-mandolin – and says that ‘the consensus is that the players of these instruments are, in reality, failed fiddlers and their music lacks the excitement and joy that is to be got from most of the other instruments’. Ouch! Neither does the bodhrán or bodhran player escape! Suffice to say that it is entertaining!

The chapters on Comhaltas and its Constitution are most important.  His role in ensuring a Constitution for Comhaltas will be part of his legacy. This is more than a social history of the organisation. Séamus Ó Dubhthaigh has provided us with a wonderful book, embellished with his wisdom and wit. May he stay forever young, bail o Dhia air.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice