Silent people

Second Reading Up to about 15 years ago, Christmas seemed to end with RTÉ’s Jim Fahy at Knock Airport.

“If you are poor in Ireland today, the argument runs, it is probably your own fault. Why don’t you, as recommended by Norman Tebbit in Thatcherite Britain, get on your bike and do something about it?”

Second Reading

Fr Kevin Hegarty

Up to about 15 years ago, Christmas seemed to end with Jim Fahy at Knock Airport. There was always a slot of Fahy on the RTÉ news, suitably funereal in tone, framed against the bleak January Connacht landscape, often with snow lakes or hailstones powdering his clothes, interviewing emigrants returning to work abroad after the Christmas interlude at home. It seemed to be the fate of Ireland in every generation to be unable to provide economic and social opportunities for all its citizens.

A heavy recession haunted the Irish economy throughout the 1980s. There was much talk of poverty then. By the mid-1990s the reality of despair had been replaced by the rhetoric of hope. David McWilliams coined the phrase, ‘the Celtic tiger’, to describe what was happening to the Irish economy. Unemployment figures plummeted. Ireland became a major player in the computer and pharmaceutical industries. ‘The Economist’, often haughty and patronising in its coverage of Irish issues, reported enthusiastically on our economic miracle.

Talk of poverty vanished from the headlines. Anyone who dared talk about the hidden pockets of poverty in Ireland met with irritation. Charlie McCreevy referred disparagingly to the ‘poverty industry’. If you are poor in Ireland today, the argument runs, it is probably your own fault. Why don’t you, as recommended by Norman Tebbit in Thatcherite Britain, get on your bike and do something about it?

So, is that all there is to be said about poverty in Ireland today? Is poverty over? Unless we are enmeshed in the tangled strands of structural poverty, we can never really understand it. Rita Ann Higgins has written powerfully in ‘Some People’:

“Some people know what it is like

To be short for the rent,

To be short for the light,

To be short for school books,

To wait in Community Welfare rooms

Full of smoke.

To wait two years to have a tooth looked at,

To wait another two years to have a

Tooth out (the same tooth),

To be half-strangled by your varicose veins,

But you’re 198th on the list.

To talk into a banana on a job search scheme

To talk into a banana on a job search dream,

To be out of money

To be out of fashion

To be out of friends

And other people don’t.”

My thoughts on poverty have been prompted by reading ‘Silent People and Other Stories’, a publication of the Combat Poverty Agency, written by journalist, Susan McKay, and powerfully illustrated by the photographs of Derek Speirs. In stark words and images, it tells the stories of 15 people out of the seven per cent, or 290,000, of our population who struggle to make ends meet each day. Among them, there is the story of Helen Stokes who lives on a halting site at Ballymun:

“Our names are down ten years for a house. Imagine that. I’ve 12 children reared in two caravans and now I’m sick. I’ve arthritis and high blood pressure. I feel I need a house. I’d sooner a house than a caravan. There is more comfort. You have a bathroom. I’ve to go outside to go to the toilet and the shower hasn’t worked for years, so I’ve to go down to my daughter’s for a bath.”

There is the story of Philip Cullen. He has no job and lives alone in a rural house that has no toilet. He is one of the men taking part in the North Leitrim Men’s Group, a FÁS scheme run in the border village of Kiltyclogher in Leitrim. He has no great hope for his future. When his time on the scheme finishes he will ‘just footer about’.

There is the story of Lesley Gardiner who feels stigmatised because she lives in Moyross in Limerick: “I’ve tried to go for jobs and people have said no, and I think it’s when they hear you are from Moyross. I was angry but I got over it. I don’t know what I’d like to do. I used to always play with barbies, so maybe a hairdresser.”

The book acknowledges that as the economy has grown “poverty levels have fallen. Economic growth has presented many people with the opportunity to escape from poverty and social exclusion.” The preface confronts those who question the existence of poverty in Ireland today. Part of the problem is that our images of poverty are drawn from starving children in the developing world or the experiences of our ancestors in the 19th century.

“This misses the point. In any society people who are unable to achieve the standards considered the norm by the majority will be alienated and discriminated against. This can have long-term consequences for people’s healthy educational outcomes and employment prospects. It also affects their ability to participate fully in society. Unless poverty is understood in relation to prevailing living standards and appropriate action is taken, people will continue to be marginalised and prevented from reaching their full potential.”

The Government has given a commitment to end poverty in the next two decades. That will remain merely a Utopian ideal unless we support it. Poverty is a scandal on the political, social and religious landscape of our society.

Last week I wrote in this column on John O’Donohue’s book ‘Benedictus’. Last Friday he died while on holiday in France. I still can’t believe it. He was such a life force. He radiated wonder and illuminated life for so many people. Ar dheis Dé go raibh a anam dílis.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice