Pope Benedict’s troubles

placeholder image

Bishop Williamson’s denial of the appalling reality of the Holocaust has landed the Pope in serious trouble. 

“To deny the appalling reality of the Holocaust is akin to claiming that it was not the failure of the potato crop, but a massive outbreak of anorexia nervosa, that caused the deaths of over one million Irish in the Great Famine of the 1840s”

Second Reading

Pope Benedict XVI has just experienced the most torrid time of his four-year-old papacy. Even those who do not share his conservative views recognise that the Pope is a sophisticated theologian, a man of deep spirituality who has a sensitive appreciation of Europe’s classical musical culture.

Conservative Catholics rejoiced in his election as Pope in April, 2005, believing he would continue the policies of John Paul II who sought to interpret the insights of the Second Vatican Council in a restrictive manner. Liberal Catholics learned of the result of the conclave with resignation. They have long ceased to believe that they can have any real influence on the official theology and administration of the Church. Unlike Cork’s star hurlers at the present time, they are willing to play but know they will never be named on the team.

After a relatively calm period of office, Pope Benedict is now in trouble on two fronts. Two weeks ago the Vatican announced the appointment of a conservative priest, Gerhard Maria Wagner, as auxiliary bishop of the Austrian city of Linz. In 2005 he claimed that Hurricane Katrina was an act of ‘divine retribution’ for the proclivities of the permissive society. He believes that environmental catastrophes are a result of spiritual pollution. New Orleans suffered because of its liberal attitude to sexual promiscuity and homosexuality.

It is not the first time that he gave a spiritual explanation for meteorological disturbances. In 2004 he asserted that it was no coincidence that the tsunami had occurred at Christmas. He stated that it was a divine punishment for ‘rich western tourists’ who had ‘fled to poor Thailand’ for the festive season. He failed to explain how it was that poor Thais who suffered most from the massive tidal wave.

Wagner’s junk theology is symptomatic of one who has spent too long in the Armageddon atmosphere of the House of Prayer on Achill rather than a priest who presumably has taken a university course in theology. It is difficult to understand how the Vatican discerned that he has the mental and moral attributes required of a bishop.

Another purveyor of junk theology, Bishop Richard Williamson, has landed the Pope in more serious trouble. Bishop Williamson is a member of the Society of Saint Pius X. Archbishop Le Febre established this society in 1970. He believed that the Second Vatican Council had deviated from the tradition and liturgy of the Church and become heretical.

He strongly opposed the Council’s ‘Declaration on Religious Liberty’, believing it the source of ‘all the reforms carried out over 20 years within the Church to please heretics, schismatics, false religions and declared enemies of the Church, such as Jews, the Communists and the Freemasons’. Matters came to a crisis in 1988 when he ordained four bishops, including Richard Williamson, thus incurring excommunication by the Vatican.

Pope Benedict has made it one of the objectives of his papacy to re-integrate dissident conservative Catholics with the Church. So recently he lifted the excommunication decree on members of the Society of St Pius X as a first step towards reconciliation.

This announcement focussed media attention on Bishop Williamson who is a Holocaust denier. In an interview on Swedish television last November, he claimed that ‘historical evidence’ was largely against six million Jews being killed as a deliberate plan of Adolf Hitler. There were no gas chambers. He estimated that no more than 300,000 Jews died in the concentration camps, as if that reduced number is a mitigation of virulent anti-semitism that lay at the heart of Nazism. To deny the appalling reality of the Holocaust is akin to claiming that it was not the failure of the potato crop, but a massive outbreak of anorexia nervosa, that caused the deaths of over one million Irish in the Great Famine of the 1840s.

Bishop Williamson’s attitude to the Holocaust is not his only foray into the fantasy world of ghoulish unreality. He believes that it was the US government who planned the 9/11 2001 terrorist atrocity and that there is a Jewish conspiracy to attain world domination. He also says that women ‘can be distracted by having their own ideas’. Wow. He deserves a gold medal for that insight into female psychology. So he disapproves of women going to university. A university is obviously no place for women who have ideas.

Pope Benedict is not a Holocaust denier. Over the years he has condemned the evils of Nazism and acknowledged the horror of the Holocaust. However, his decision to rehabilitate Williamson has incurred the opposition not just of Jewish leaders, but also of Angela Merkel, the German Chancellor, and senior clerics, like Cardinal Murphy O’Connor, normally loath to criticise the Vatican. It has shown the danger of seeking reconciliation with dissident conservative Catholics, many of whom carry sulphurous political and theological baggage. It has placed Catholic-Jewish dialogue in serious jeopardy.

Hans Kung, the liberal Catholic theologian, long out of favour with the Vatican, has argued that there can be no peace between the nations without peace between the religions. Pope Benedict once commented that: “I am like the cellist Rostropovich, I never read the critics.” Alright, but maybe it is time he gave Hans Kung a call.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice