OPINION: Centralist clericalism is finally giving way

PEOPLE POWER The synodal process is moving the Catholic Church away from the centrality of the clerical world towards the world of the people of God, the laity. Pic: Alfredo Borba/cc-by-sa 2.0placeholder image
PEOPLE POWER The synodal process is moving the Catholic Church away from the centrality of the clerical world towards the world of the people of God, the laity. Pic: Alfredo Borba/cc-by-sa 2.0

In his De Facto column, Liamy MacNally looks at the trends emerging from last month's Synod in Rome

HUNDREDS of people gathered in Rome for the Synod over the past month. It was a gathering of the faithful from all levels of church to discern not just ‘Where to from here?’ but more ‘How to from here…’. The past month was the end of stage one of a process that began in 2021. Stage two will be this time next year. God knows when that part will end.

It means that from now on, the process of ‘being church’ will not only involve clerics at the head of the hierarchical structure making all the decisions but more of an inverted pyramid, where everyone has a say and everyone’s view is important. The era of ‘una duce, una voce’ is over – on paper anyway.

The synodal process is more like the peace process: ongoing. This is about the journeying rather than the destination.

Up to now, the hierarchy were central in all Roman Catholic Church decision-making. That is all about to change (eventually). Unfortunately, it still appears as if the penny hasn’t dropped with some of them. They are like the priest who, returning from the Second Vatican Council (Vatican II) in Rome in the 1960s was asked about forthcoming church changes. ‘No changes’, he quipped, ever so seriously.

Essentially, for reluctant clerics and pre-Vatican II devotees, this synodal process is really Vatican II for beginners. Vatican II took place from 1962-65 and produced 16 documents, which dealt with various issues from liturgy and its practice to doctrine, theology of the church, ecumenism and religious freedom. While certain issues were implemented and some change took place – like Mass in the vernacular rather than Latin – other issues were ignored or quietly abandoned. Pope Francis is now dusting them down.

In the Catholic Church, we have people who wish today were yesterday and others who wish tomorrow were today. Pope Francis is attempting to steer people back to the present, sit around a table, listen to each other’s different viewpoint and pray together to discern what it is that the Holy Spirit is prompting the Church to do.

God can’t be contained by the pre-Vatican II Latin-lovers in the same way that He can’t be defined by liberals who want women priests. We all make the same mistake when we rejig that scripture verse, ‘Speak Lord, your servant is listening’ to read ‘Listen Lord, your servant is speaking’. It’s usually difficult for us to think that we are wrong, especially when it comes to faith matters.

The great joy of the synodal process is that it is a serious attempt to move away from the centrality of the clerical world towards the world of the people of God, also known by that terrible word, laity. Clericalism has dominated the church for centuries. It has run its course and has no place in the world we live in today as believers living in a civil society.

Believers all share baptism; that is our common denominator. It is the cornerstone of faith and the sacraments. It also has to become the starting point of Church governance. Everyone is baptised as ‘priest, prophet and king’. It is the priesthood of baptism that unites us, not the clerical priesthood. Not only does baptism unite people it also makes them equal, regardless, man, woman, black, white, gay, bi, straight… the list goes on. No one is denied the love of God.

We are witnessing what the Association of Catholic Priests (ACP) used as its AGM theme this year, ‘The Last Priests of Ireland’. For example, the 52 parishes in Tuam archdiocese has only about 40 priests under the retirement age of 75 (Yes, priests cannot retire until they’re 75!), and similar trends are replicated across the country. The ACP AGM was told last week of some priests still ‘expected to work’ even in their 90s. If all retired priests in Ireland decided together to stop saying parish Masses, the show would be over.

Our churches are emptying more quickly following Covid. What can we do to arrest the decline of public worship? The synodal process is the answer. It’s about service, not power, sitting with fellow believers, acknowledging the differences, praying together, and proceeding as one, unity in diversity… a slow journey.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice