Minister critisied for not holding enquiry

Galway based Councilor critisises Minister for not action on the sinking of a Rosport residents boat

Minister criticised by councillor for response to Council motion

Anton McNulty

THE decision by the Minister for Justice not to hold an inquiry into the sinking of a fishing boat belonging to a Shell to Sea supporter has been criticised by Galway councillor who called for an inquiry.

The Iona Isle, owed by Erris fisherman and Shell to Sea supporter Pat O’Donnell sank in controversial circumstances in Broadhaven Bay in June 2009. Mr O’Donnell claimed that at 4am on June 10, his boat was boarded by men in wetsuits and he was held in the wheelhouse before the boat’s engine cut out and it started to flood.

An all-party motion was passed by Galway City Council last March calling for a public inquiry into the sinking of the Iona Isle. In a reply to Galway City Council, which was reported last week, the Minister for Justice, Dermot Ahern outlined that there was no evidence of third-party involvement in the sinking of the Iona Isle and the law officials have directed no prosecution.

Former Galway mayor, Cllr Catherine Connolly told The Irish Times that she was ‘very disappointed’ by the Minister’s response to the motion and felt it was clear he had no intention of initiating an inquiry.

“Why is Mr Ahern’s response only being made public at this time – nine months after the city council’s motion, and within days of an An Bord PleanΡla decision on the final section of the Corrib gas project,” she said.

“We have not yet been forwarded his letter, but it is clear that he is just repeating the findings of a Garda investigation, and I would question why this has been given to a newspaper before we were aware of his response.”

At the time of the sinking, Mr O’Donnell and his crewman, Martin McDonnell took to a life raft and reported the incident to Belmullet Garda Station at 4.43am, and said that four men had sped north in a boat. Shell issued a statement denying any involvement.

The boat was never salvaged and on November 23, 2009, Mr O’Donnell was informed that the DPP directed there would be no prosecution. Mr O’Donnell told The Irish Times that he had not been happy with the Garda investigation at the time. “How do the gardaí know there was no third-party involvement, when they did not set up checkpoints at ports after I had reported the sinking,” he said.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice