‘Major barrier to access justice’ - Mayo woman calls for reform of ‘rape shield’ law


Ireland's "rape shield" law routinely failing to protect complainants, new research finds.
Ireland's so-called "rape shield" law is routinely failing to stop complainants in sexual offence trials from being cross-examined about their previous sexual experiences, according to new independent research from Maynooth University launched by Rape Crisis Ireland (RCI).
The report, What's Sex Got to Do with It? Sexual Experience Evidence in Irish Rape Trials, was written by Dr Sinéad Ring, Associate Professor of Law at Maynooth University's School of Law and Criminology. It is an independent academic report supported by RCI.
It is the first qualitative study of section 3 of the Criminal Law (Rape) Act 1981, which governs when evidence about a complainant's sexual history may be introduced at trial. The report draws on 21 in-depth interviews with barristers, solicitors, policy specialists, court accompaniment workers and Legal Aid clerks who have direct experience of how the law operates in practice.
"Surprisingly high" figure
The report found that in 2025, at least 39% of sexual offence trials involved an application to introduce evidence of, or to cross-examine a complainant on, their sexual history. The report describes that figure as surprisingly high.
While overt character attacks on complainants have declined, the report says applications to admit such evidence still rely on the same discredited assumptions the law was designed to prevent: that prior consent suggests future consent, and that a complainant's sexual history affects their credibility.
Dr Ring explained that the law prohibits questioning or evidence about a complainant's previous sexual history in a sexual offence case unless it is relevant.
"It's not a total ban, and I'm not arguing there should be one," she said. "But the current rule is supposed to be quite a heavy restriction on the introduction of this kind of evidence and this kind of questioning, and it's not working."
Groups at particular risk
The report identifies two groups at particularly high risk of intrusive cross-examination: adults who were in a relationship with the accused, and child or adolescent complainants. The latter are often questioned on issues far removed from the alleged offence, including social media use and access to pornography.
It also raises concerns about timing. Section 3 applications are frequently made with little notice, sometimes on the first day of trial. This limits complainants' ability to engage meaningfully with the process and puts significant pressure on the Legal Aid Board to secure a Separate Legal Representative (SLR) at short notice. SLRs represent complainants' interests during these hearings, and the report finds that their quality and experience vary considerably.
Calls for reform
Proponents of reform, including Dr Ring, argue that the law relies on outdated and discredited myths about consent. Dr Ring is calling for a clearer definition of the limited exceptions in which a person's previous sexual history can be admitted into evidence.
Mayo’s Ciara Mangan, founder of Beyond Surviving, welcomed the report as "a welcomed insight into what survivors are up against in their pursuit of justice and accountability, which should serve to inform reform" of this area of law.
"This report shows 39% of sexual offence trials last year involved an application to admit sexual history evidence, when we know these are based on long contested misconceptions on what causes rape," the Castlebar campaigner said.
"We know from our own survey report at Beyond Surviving that the intrusion of one's privacy in the courtroom, and the mere anticipation of such, is a deep concern for survivors. Survivors tell us they often feel powerless to protect their dignity in court, affecting their decisions to engage meaningfully in the criminal justice system."
She also raised the lack of notice as a further concern. "When applications are made on the first day of trial, survivors have no time to understand what's being sought, prepare, or get support," she said.
"That is a major barrier to access to justice. We welcome this report and want to see reform that gives survivors clear, early information and genuine, fair opportunities to engage in a process that holds great power over their lives."
Survivors' views
Survivors who commented on the findings were scathing. One said: "I find using any of the victims' sexual history in a court absolutely abhorrent and completely unacceptable."
Another drew a comparison with fraud cases: "It's another strand of victim blaming in sexual assault cases that has no place in the justice system in 2026.
If you change the word 'rape' to 'fraud' and think about someone who was defrauded giving evidence in court against the fraudster, asking someone where else they spent money, or their financial history, seems utterly outrageous, and irrelevant to them being defrauded. Of course it wasn't their fault. Why is rape different?"
