Lisbon for slow learners?


Opponents of the Lisbon Treaty currently seem a bedraggled minority, though they will regroup.
SEAMUS Mallon once famously described the Good Friday Agreement of 1998 as ‘Sunningdale for slow learners’. He was referring to the 1974 agreement which in its basic lineaments, was similar to the structures negotiated in 1998. Sunningdale failed due to Unionist intransigence, IRA violence and the British government’s incompetence. The failure presaged over 20 years of further violent conflict in Northern Ireland.
Are we about to witness a similar conversion regarding the Lisbon Treaty? Last June voters in the Irish Republic emphatically rejected the treaty. Opinion polls indicate the result would be different if a referendum was held now. More decisively, of the 12 MEP’s elected to the European Parliament on June 5, only one, Joe Higgins, opposes the treaty.
Libertas, the pan-European party, which ran an effective campaign against the treaty last year, was lacerated by electorates throughout the European Union. Its leader, Declan Ganley, after a respectable though unsuccessful showing, has retired from the political arena and returned to the world of business. The Libertas bandwagon has collapsed with the rapidity of a pricked balloon.
Why this change in public opinion? It is partly due to the success of the government, in negotiations with our European partners, in addressing concerns that emerged during last year’s campaign regarding the commissionership, our neutrality, our taxation system and our family laws.
Many voters approached last year’s referendum in a cavalier fashion. They either didn’t vote or voted no on the basis that they did not understand the treaty and made little effort to deepen their knowledge. Others used the referendum to register their disapproval of a government they had voted into office the previous year. They were shocked by the depths of disappointment felt throughout the European Union by our result.
More importantly the economic crisis, which has dominated our lives since last autumn, has forced a re-think on our attitude to the Union. We now realise that our open economy needs all the help it can get. In stormy weather one does not question the provenance of a lifeboat.
Opponents of the Lisbon Treaty currently seem a bedraggled minority, though, probably, given their proven tenacity at evading reality, they will regroup somewhat before next autumn when the new referendum is held. Most of the anti-Lisbon rhetoric in recent days has come from Mary Lou McDonald of Sinn Féin and Patricia McKenna, both of whom were defeated in the European election.
In a Guardian article last Thursday, Tim Garton Ash pointed to the ironical similarities between Sinn Féin and the British Conservative party in relation to Lisbon.
He quoted from the 2008 Sinn Féin guide to Lisbon: “It gives the EU too much power and reduces our ability to stop decisions that are not in Ireland’s interests. It gives 105 additional powers to the EU on issues such as international relations, security, trade and economic policy. And in more than 60 of those areas we will lose our right to stop laws not in our national interest.”
Garton Ash commented: “Replace ‘Ireland’ with ‘Britain’ and reprint at Conservative central office. Surely Gerry Adams and David Cameron should campaign together.”
The political heirs of Bobby Sands and Margaret Thatcher on the one platform - that should draw a crowd. Sinn Féin will have to revise significantly its attitude to the European Union if it hopes to achieve its ambition of serving in the government of the Irish Republic.
As reasons for a reversal of last year’s verdict on Lisbon, those given above fall far short of enthusiasm for the European project. However, Brian Cowen, after a punishing year in the Taoiseach’s chair, must find them comforting.
I believe that the European Union has been the most positive development in the post Second World War world. It has brought peace and relative economic stability to Western Europe. As Margo Wallstrom, Vice-President of the European Commission, wrote recently, “Two generations of Europeans have grown up without knowing what it is like to have a war in their country.” A substantial advance on the previous half-century which was disfigured by two world wars and other lesser, though painful conflicts.
So far as Ireland is concerned, the European Union has played a major role in modernising our political, social and economic infrastructure. it has helped us overcome our cultural insularity. Patrick Kavanagh wrote of a time when Ireland “froze” for want of Europe. It has reconnected us with mainland Europe. It has lessened our dependance on Britain which, given its debilitating colonial overtones, had a negative impact on our development.
Couched in forbidding legal and bureaucratic language, the Lisbon Treaty is not a devilish monster but a mechanism designed to help a community of 27 nations function efficiently.
As Seamus Heaney implied in his recent intervention in the Lisbon Treaty campaign, “Our honour and our identity” are at stake in the forthcoming referendum.