In the Nama the Father

Westport’s thorny Garden of Edenplaceholder image
Westport’s thorny Garden of Eden

We know little about NAMA, other than we could be in hock to bankers and developers for up to €90 billion.

MANY of us only heard the term ‘subprime’ when the recession started to kick in.  The term emanated from America where banks were engaged in subprime mortgages.  These are mortgages made out to people with lower credit ratings.  Interest rates are normally higher because the risk is greater.  The first credit scoring system for investments was introduced by the Fair Issac Corporation (FICO) in 1958, and for bank credit cards in 1970.  Subprime loans were for those whose FICO score was below 640 points.  In America some bankers started to ‘sell’ these mortgages on to other financial institutions, so what started as a high-risk mortgage was being brokered around the money markets like gold dust.  The dust description was correct, but gold it certainly was not.    

The American subprime mortgage industry suffered a serious increase in the number of defaults.  More than one hundred subprime mortgage lenders went bust or filed for bankruptcy.  One commentator stated: “The failure of these companies has caused prices in the $6.5 trillion mortgage backed securities market to collapse, threatening broader impacts on the US housing market and economy as a whole… However, the crisis has had far-reaching consequences across the world.  Tranches of sub-prime debts were repackaged by banks and trading houses into attractive-looking investment vehicles and securities that were snapped up by banks, traders and hedge funds on the US, European and Asian markets.  Thus, when the crisis hit the subprime mortgage industry, those who bought into the market suddenly found their investments near-valueless - or impossible to accurately value… As a result, ordinary, run-of-the-mill and healthy businesses across the world with no direct connection whatsoever to US sub-prime suddenly started facing difficulties or even folding due to the banks unwillingness to budge on credit lines.”  It all sounds too familiar at this stage!

In the context of the subprime dance of death that has been imported to many countries from the US it raises certain questions about our very own National Asset Management Agency, NAMA.  We know very little about its operation, other than that we, as a nation, could be in hock to that new cross-breed, bankers/developers, for up to €90 billion.  We have no earthly concept of that amount of money, even €10 billion is enough to scare most of us.  We think of it in terms of the under spend in the BMW Region during the boom years!    

NAMA is still in its Government wrapping paper, apart from the fact that we now know that we now know we are all shareholders in about €3 billion worth of property in the US that has come under NAMA’s radar.  What we do not know is the real value of property in the current market.  What we also do not know is how close the NAMA debacle could be to the principle used in the subprime markets.  Are we buying €90 billion of pure risk?  That would be like committing national suicide.  Where are the Green Party members, apart from bleating platitudes about NAMA?  Too often their record in government has been one of capitulation and inaction, allowing the colour of power to dye their principles.  The only ‘subprime’ certainty is this current Government.    

The opening preacher at the recent Knock Novena was Cardinal Seán Brady.  He spoke about Pope Benedict’s recent encyclical Charity in Truth.  “The Pope calls for economic activity ‘carried out by subjects who freely choose to act according to principles other than those of pure profit.’  There he would include economic entities that draw their origin from both religious and lay initiatives.  I would love to see some of our many serious and distinguished economic analysts reflect upon and tease out the implications of what the Pope has said.  It is probably an understatement to say that confidence in many commercial banks is declining and that disillusionment has set in.  Has the time not come for responsible Catholic economists to take the lead in developing some, not for profit, systems of lending, saving and insurance, built on an ethic of authentic human development?  Such initiatives would certainly increase the hope of a more humane and ethically robust economy.  The Credit Union is one such initiative.  The Knights of Columbus Ethical Investment Programme in the US is another.  It would be tragic if nothing is learned from this recession.  There is one thing we could all learn – a certain wariness.  Pope Benedict recommends being wary of ‘a speculative use of financial resources that leads to the temptation of seeking only short-term profit, without regard for the long-term sustainability of the enterprise.’” 

Professed Catholics among the thinking class and economists who can develop this wisdom in ethical banking can contact Cardinal Brady at Ara Coeli, Cathedral Road, Armagh, BT61 7QY.  Tel (048) 3752 2045.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice