High Court quashes coroner’s decision to omit HSA report into Achill woman’s death

The High Court say that a HSA report into Achill woman’s death in Mulranny should not be excluded from her inquest.

High Court quashes coroner’s decision

Anton McNulty

THE father of an Achill woman who was killed in a road traffic accident near Mulranny in 2004 has expressed relief after the High Court quashed a coroner’s decision to exclude a Health and Safety Authority report from her inquest.

Tommy Gallagher, the father of Aisling Gallagher (pictured) from Askill on Achill Island told The Mayo News that he was relieved with the High Court decision. The court heard that the HSA report found that the cause of the accident, which claimed the life of 22-year-old Aisling, was due to the surface of the road.

However, the conclusions of this report are disputed by Mayo County Council and the coroner for south Mayo, John O’Dwyer ruled last April to exclude the report from the inquest. A judicial review was brought by the Gallagher family and last Friday, Mr Justice Liam McKechnie, ruled that Mr O’Dwyer decision was ‘legally incorrect’ on the grounds that no reasons were provided and set aside the decision.

Speaking to The Mayo News following the decision, Tommy Gallagher explained that they were relieved that the Judge had ruled in their favour and added that if he had not, it would have serious implications for inquests in the future.

“We will go into the inquest with the full story which is what we wanted because there is no point playing if the deck is marked. If they [Mayo County Council] had been successful it would have reduced the role of the coroner to that of rubber stamping a pathologist’s report.”

Aisling Gallaghrt died on December 22, 2004 when the van she was driving was involved in a collision with a cement mixer lorry on the N59 Newport to Mulranny road. At the time, the road, where Mayo County Council was carrying out resurfacing works, was coated with a temporary road surface, deep bitumen macadam (DBM), which Tommy Gallagher claims is notoriously slippery without a chipped gripping surface on top. Mayo County Council deny any responsibility.

The family have campaigned for the cause of her death to be investigated fully and have gone to Europe on the matter. The inquest into Aisling’s death has been adjourned on numerous occasions and Tommy Gallagher said he still has no idea when it will heard but expected to get a ‘fair’ inquest. He explained that the decision by Mayo County Council to contest the cause of the accident had turned the matter into a ‘battle’.

“It is five years since Aisling died and this is an awful long time for this to be dragging on. All we are getting is kicked in the teeth and the runaround by every Government department going. The NRA claimed they were taking a neutral position but their Head of Operations, Pat Maher, was at the court hearing for the full day,” he said.

During the hearing - which lasted a full day - Senior Counsels representing Mayo Council, the NRA, the Coroner and the Gallagher family all made submissions on the matter. Mayo County Council argued that the coroner's decision was correct, while the NRA, said they had concerns about the accuracy of the HSA report.

In his judgment Mr Justice McKechnie said that it was difficult for the court to identify reasons why the coroner had refused to allow the HSA report to be used in the inquest. The matter is now remitted back to the coroner.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice