Over 200 cases listed for Mayo court sitting as backlog intensifies


The number of cases in Castlebar District Court balloons to 219 as the legal aid dispute continues between solicitors and the Department of Justice
The backlog of cases in Mayo courts caused by the current solicitors dispute is expected to intensify with over 200 cases listed to be heard at tomorrow's sitting of Castlebar District Court.
Solicitors in Mayo withdrew their services in the local courts after the Minister for Justice brought in changes to the legal aid scheme on July 1 which has resulted in cases being continuously adjourned and not dealt with.
The adjourning of cases since July has resulted in a major backlog of cases with 219 cases scheduled to be heard at tomorrow's sitting of Castlebar District Court. The number of cases normally heard at Castlebar District Court is normally half what is listed for tomorrow's sitting with the majority of the 219 cases expected to be adjourned.
The backlog of cases is expected to intensify in the coming weeks with no end in sight for the dispute. Solicitors staged a walk-out of Castlebar Courthouse on Monday to highlight the ongoing dispute with all solicitors in Mayo having now withdrawn from the legal aid panel.
Judge Eoin Garavan commented at Monday's sitting of Castlebar Circuit Criminal Court that the court system in Mayo was reaching a crisis and in danger of being overwhelmed because of the back log of cases.
“It is going to be potentially overwhelming for the court and certainly those now appearing in the list can expect many years before their cases can be dealt with and that is unacceptable.
“As far as I am concerned the position in Mayo is now getting critical and I can only hope that meaningful talks in this dispute can be resolved as soon as possible. There are too many people not working and too many cases not being finalised and that is not an acceptable situation,” he said.
Judge Garavan compared the backlog of cases to what happened during Covid but added that there was little crime occurring at the height of the pandemic while crime today is continuing.
Solicitors whose clients do not receive legal aid have also withdrawn their services in solidarity meaning that all criminal cases are not proceedings.
In recent weeks, district court judges have informed solicitors representing defendants not receiving legal aid that they will expect these cases to continue but to date the majority of solicitors have not returned to the courtroom to deal with them.
Gary Mulchrone, President of the Mayo Solicitors Bar Association said that solicitors want to return to work but claimed they have been forced to take their stance by the failure of the Department of Justice to negotiate changes to the new legal aid scheme.
“Everyone working in the system is feeling the pain and understands the impact of this dispute but yet it would appear it is being downplayed and typified by a failure to engage and resolve and medicate which has been quite striking.
“I am sorry to see so many people needlessly discommoded by this period of upheaval and I know my colleagues in the Bar [barristers] have been deeply hurt as well by this dispute and colleagues across the county have suffered for over four months with no income from the work in this area.
“Jobs depend on this income, local jobs and local people and yet it seems there is no recognition for that and I am astounded that this disruption has now become the norm over the last four months.
“I do hope we will return soon but the answer to that question does not lie with us, it lies squarely at the feet of one person who could end the dispute today if he so wished,” he said.
