Convicted of dumping at Achill beauty spot
A woman was convicted of creating litter in a public place in Achill District Court last week, after evidence was heard that an environmental enforcement officer abseiled down a cliff on the island to remove rubbish which had been illegally dumped on a rocky ledge.
Convicted of dumping at Achill beauty spot
A woman was convicted of creating litter in a public place in Achill District Court last week, after evidence was heard that an environmental enforcement officer abseiled down a cliff on the island to remove rubbish which had been illegally dumped on a rocky ledge.
Ms Lisa Guthrie, Kildownet, Achill, pleaded not guilty to the charge of creating litter that is visible from a public place.
Maria O’Connell, Environmental Enforcement Officer with Mayo County Council, told the court that with the assistance of Civil Defence personnel, she abseiled to the ledge on the cliff where dumped material had accumulated. She said it was a 30-foot drop to the ledge and a further 20 foot down to the sea below.
She added that there were six intact bags of rubbish on top of other waste that had gathered over time. Ms Guthrie’s name and address was found on an envelope at the site and the total cost of the clean-up was €4,375. The court heard that it was a French tourist who had alerted authorities to the illegal dumping of household waste on the Atlantic Drive.
Defending solicitor, Garret Bourke, argued that the defendant’s name is Lisa John and that she has always been known by this name. He said there was no person by the name of Lisa Guthrie living in the area. However, the defendant admitted during cross-examination by Ward McEllin, solicitor for Mayo County Council, that she had been living with a man named Guthrie and that her children were known by that surname.
Judge Devins said there was a presumption that Lisa John was Lisa Guthrie and that this presumption had not been rebutted by the evidence. She found the defendant guilty of the offence and fined her €500. She also ordered her to pay a €750 contribution to the cost of cleaning up the area plus a further €500 costs for legal expenses and VAT.