Politicians must stand strong on all issues, not some


EDITORIAL Politicians need to ‘take the hand’ of women battling the HSE during the fallout from the recent screening scandals
‘NOT GOOD ENOUGH’ Shay McGreal speaking at a recent vigil for the victims of the cervical cancer scandal in Westport. McGreal (pictured here with another speaker, Tara Bleeks) spoke with passion and conviction about his partner of twenty two years, Deirdre Feehan, who passed away in December 2017 from cervical cancer. He spoke again at a Standing 4 Women rally in Castlebar last Wednesday. Pic: Alison Laredo
The message from the people of Ireland on Friday, May 25, was abundantly clear – Ireland has to change.
The Yes side won by a landslide to repeal the Eighth Amendment.
It’s rare that you will ever see politicians fêted as heroes. But in those heady hours in the run up to the result being announced on May 26, and in the days that followed, Fine Gael politicians like Leo Varadkar and Simon Harris were as popular as any politician ever will be.
And while the result is being championed as a breakthrough in how women are treated in this country, it did not take even one week for doubts to emerge about any such assertion.
The cervical cancer scandal raged before the referendum, and it will rage long after.
On May 2, it was revealed that national cervical screening programme CervicalCheck failed to inform 209 women, and the relatives of 18 deceased women, of an incorrect smear-test result.
Ultimate accountability does lie with the politicians, but it would be wrong to blame them entirely for the scandal.
Brian Cowen once described the Department of Health as ‘Angola’, and it still resembles a war zone. Countless politicians have tried and failed to bring it up to the standards expected of a First World health service, so some allowance has to be made for the fact that Minister for Health Simon Harris and Taoiseach Leo Varadkar are not long in their positions (although Varadkar was previously Minister for Health).
Accountability for what happened has to rest more squarely with those responsible directly. Accountability is something we don’t see much of in most branches of the public service, however.
That said, Messrs Harris and Varadkar must step up and be men of their word with regards to the assurances and promises they made in the days and weeks since this scandal emerged.
And it only emerged thanks to the heroic and brave public service (in the truest sense of the phrase) Vicky Phelan performed. Ms Phelan had to endure a court battle and resist a confidentiality clause that the HSE pushed for in order to make this issue public, when it ought to have been so long before her defiant action.
Déjà vu
In May, both Varadkar and Harris said everything would be done for victims of the scandal and nobody would be forced to go to court.
“Is is wrong that any terminally ill woman would be dragged through the courts … We are going to ensure that no woman ever finds herself in Vicky Phelan’s place again,” said Minister Harris.
However, in recent days we have heard of the treatment of terminally ill cancer sufferer Emma Mhic Mhathúna.
Ms Mhic Mhathúna is another incredibly brave Irish citizen who has done far more for her country than it deserves, considering how terribly it has treated her.
In the first instance, she is now terminally ill due to the shocking misdiagnosis. And to add considerable insult to terminal illness, the HSE is refusing to admit liability.
Furthermore the HSE seems content to allow the legal team for Question Diagnostics, the Texas lab where her smear test was incorrectly read, to subject Ms Mhic Mhathúna and her five children, who range in age from two to 16, to further anguish.
The Irish Independent revealed on Friday that the legal team for Question Diagnostics sought to have Ms Mhic Mhathúna’s children questioned by a psychologist for up to two hours each, to assess the impact their mother’s death would have on them.
It truly beggars belief.
If you are a women faced with the same situation Ms Mhic Mhathúna finds herself in, would you be encouraged to seek redress when you see what she has to endure? Why would you put yourself through that?
Ms Mhic Mhathúna says she is persisting for one reason only – to ensure her children are taken care of after she dies. Her children will never forget their mother’s heroism, but the reality is they should not be facing into a future without their mother.
And instead of being able to spend whatever precious time they have left with their mother around, they’ve to endure her being challenged in the courts—something Varadkar and Harris vowed would not happen.
Who’s in charge?
Who is in charge of this country? Who is in charge of our health service? It appears not to be the two men who were gladly receiving the high fives and slaps on their backs last week.
Either they are in charge and they should sort this out immediately, or else their mouths should not write cheques they cannot cash.
Last Wednesday, at a Standing 4 Women rally in Castlebar, Westport man Shay McGreal summed up the feeling of many.
“Last Friday the Repeal of the Eighth Amendment was carried quite strongly, and on the television I saw Leo Varadkar and our Minister for Health, Simon Harris, clapping each other on the back and making a big woohoo about how they’ve changed how healthcare will be provided for women in this country.
“Well this cervical cancer scandal is also a women’s health issue … I heard both of them saying their motto ‘Please don’t take the boat, take our hand’. Well how about they take these women’s hands and help them out, and deal with it in a compassionate and humane way. These are people after all, not just numbers. They’ve got families and they’ve got children, they’ve got friends. It’s simply not good enough so if they want to give themselves a clap on the back about doing all this for women’s healthcare, let them deal with this one properly and openly.”
And so say all of us.