OUTDOORS: How insurance is crippling small local producers
Chris Brown argues that extortionate insurance requirements are choking the life out of local enterprises.
Insurance – is somebody going to say something?
Growing your own
Chris Brown
I used to think that insurance held back enterprise in Ireland. It seemed to be a stumbling block placed there to stop people from doing things. Now, many years later, I’m absolutely certain of it!
What’s my beef? Let me tell you.
Like many a small farmer trying to make a living from the land, I face an uphill struggle to make ends meet due to poor access to the market place. We produce organic lamb and pork, but faced with accepting a pathetic ‘factory price’ at a distant abattoir (all the local ones have closed down) which doesn’t even cover the cost of creating such top-quality meat, we should be afforded the opportunity of selling our product elsewhere.
This we endeavour to do by crafting handmade artisan food, turning our organic lambs into spicy lamburgers and our pigs into free-range sausages. We then cook them and serve a delicious taste of Mayo food to the public. By doing this we add value to our product, which is important if we are to survive financially.
Ever mindful of the ‘Food Miles’ issues facing us all, I thought one of our local beaches would be a good place to trade, and converted an old mobile butcher’s shop into a trailer that could be towed the quarter-mile from a nearby farm by tractor each day. This meant there was no engine involved – after all a person visiting the beach wants to hear the sound of the ocean not a diesel motor chugging away and spewing fumes.
Parked up so as not to spoil anyone’s view and providing re-cycling facilities for glass, cans and compost for anyone using the strand, we felt the comfort of finding hot local food and a warm drink was an attraction to visitors. We understood a permit would be necessary and travelled to get one.
Aside from the fact that the permit would cost €400, Mayo County Council refused to issue one unless we increased our insurance cover to a staggering €6.4 million. The same would apply, unbelievably, to a market stall.
Now our insurance policy is one of ‘multi peril’, which covers for a claim of up to €2.4 million; a vast amount of money.
To put this figure into context, I recall an incident in the Claremorris area of the county, when, at a school re-union, a bowl of hot soup was tipped over a woman, who decided to sue. Both the caterer and the school were found to be 50/50 liable and an award of €7,000 was made.
Take a look at the amount. If three people had all copped for the soup on the lap, it is possible that €21,000 may have been awarded. Times this amount by ten and reach €210,000. Our cover of €2.4 million is more than ten times this again.
Why would a council make a stipulation like this?
When I inquired if there had ever been a claim where €2.4 million was not enough, I was told I wasn’t entitled to this information.
Now, with the costs at over €800 for permit and insurance to trade for the few weeks of summer (weather permitting) few will be surprised to hear that no refreshments are available at any of our beaches – unlike abroad, where knowledge of tourism is better understood.
And it’s not just the beaches. Westport Farmer’s Market, which began with over 20 stalls has, due to high insurance costs, dwindled dramatically. My friend who makes beautiful hand-made cards is also required to have a €6.4 million policy. She now plans to finish up because of the insurance burden.
We stare down the barrel of a recession, and the insurance cartel and its enforcers are stopping us from supporting ourselves.
Next time Growing food – the challenge of our times
> Chris Brown runs Brown’s Farm, a small farm in Louisburgh. He is an advocate of sustainable, natural farming methods and buying local.