FILM REVIEW Dear John


Based on a tear-jerker by Nicholas Sparks, ‘Dear John’ tells the story of a whirlwind, long-distance romance.
Dear John, wake me up when it’s over
Cinema
Daniel Carey
FOR a small segment of ‘Dear John’, I thought the eponymous character’s name was John Terry. His surname is actually Tyree, and he seems to have more redeeming qualities than the disgraced captain of Chelsea Football Club. But though he’s no John Terry (in every sense), he’s not that likeable either.
Nor, indeed, is the film that bears his name. John (Channing Tatum) first meets Savannah (Amanda Seyfried, who played Meryl Streep’s daughter in ‘Mamma Mia!’) after rescuing her handbag from the water. They spend two weeks together before he has to go back to serving as a US soldier in Germany, but it’s enough time for them to fall in love.
John describes his work as involving ‘long stretches of boring’ and ‘occasional flashes of scary’. Substitute the word ‘schmaltzy’ for ‘scary’, and you have an idea of what you’re in for with this movie. Director Lasse Hallström stayed the right side of cheap sobs for the most part with ‘The Cider House Rules’, but frequently jumps over the line here – and leaves the audience cold.
Based on a tear-jerker by Nicholas Sparks, ‘Dear John’ tells the story of a whirlwind romance that is later conducted at long distance. Although it is set at the turn of the century, mobile phones don’t get a look-in – communications are by by hand-written letter.
This should be rich, if well-trodden territory. Some letters from the front make for extremely poignant reading, and almost 100 years on, the thoughts of ordinary soldiers in World War I can bring that conflict to life. But ‘Dear John’ never threatens to grab you in the same way. Something has got lost in the post here.
The 9/11 attack on the World Trade Center, a shot-through-the-heart letter, a shooting and two illnesses means that a fair bit happens in the closing stages. But viewers are likely to be left flummoxed – either by the murky motivations involved, and/or the film-makers’ shamelessness. In a bizarre effort to ensure there are no bad guys, we end up in a situation where there is nobody to identify with either.
The war action scenes are just that – action. We see soldiers run, shoot and blow things up. But for all armed conflict brings to the plot, John could just as easily be on an oil rig in the North Sea as serving in uniform.
The best parts of the picture are when the two leads are together. Some of the motifs established in the early stages – rare coins, the size of the moon – reoccur throughout, and give those looking for needles in this haystack something to grab on to. Richard Jenkins is his reliable self as John’s autistic father, while Seyfried brings good cheer to Savannah, a character who promises her squeeze that she has ‘plenty of faults’. If anyone can name three, I’d like to hear them.
Tatum is good-looking, but from the start, I was completely mystified as to what Savannah sees in John. She’s bubbly and outgoing; he’s not just strong and silent, but seems to lack any personality.
When I heard that ‘Dear John’ was responsible for kicking ‘Avatar’ off top spot at the US box-office back in February, I presumed it was a victory for girl power. But my female companion’s verdict on this so-called ‘chick flick’ consisted of one word, beginning with ‘s’ and ending in ‘e’ – and it wasn’t ‘sublime’. On that basis, I can only assume there are a hell of a lot of teenage girls going to see it.
Rating 3 out of 10