Coaching - reform or revolution?


A man at a club match recently called for internment for coaches, but Ray Dempsey’s reformist approach may work better
Coaching – reform or revolution?
“I THINK internment would want to be introduced for coaches, that’s what’s wrong,” one spectator told another shortly before a recent club championship match. “Lock the f***ers up for about five years!”
Having only come into the vicinity seconds before this radical proposal was put forward, I’ve no idea in what led up to it. Was this a remark in the Conor Hayes tradition, an attempt to bring the ‘We didn’t go overboard with tactics’ mindset of the former Galway hurling manager to Gaelic football? Was it a general plea for a back-to-basics approach, where strength and conditioning, diet and ball work are abandoned in favour of a more traditional bacon and cabbage lifestyle where training consists of multiple laps and little else?
Coaching is a curious thing. In February 2006, shortly after Steve Staunton was appointed manager of the Republic of Ireland soccer team, Tom Colohan penned an interesting article in the Longford Leader. “Is Stan the man?” he asked in ‘Colohan’s Corner’. “He might be. One thing is certain though – his CV would not have got him an interview with the FAI as a coach for underage soccer in Longford. Why? Because he has got no coaching qualifications.”
Different sports take different approaches to coaching. Famously, Roy Keane didn’t take the training sessions while he was manager of Sunderland, but there was little doubt that he was the boss. Some GAA coaches take an unconventional approach to both on- and off-field matters – John Morrison famously produced a skip and asked the Mayo footballers to leave their negative baggage in it.
But while both soccer and GAA coaches may have to defer to a manager, what a rugby coach says goes. This may explain the lengths Trevor Brennnan went to please then-Ireland Head Coach Warren Gatland. When Brennan complained he was feeling tired, Gatland suggested he have four to five bananas at training.
The following day, Brennan approached the coach, looking slightly embarrassed. “I’ve tried,” said the back row forward, “but today I’ve only managed 29”. The New Zealander admits that some Irish players often had problems with his accent, and Brennan was obviously one of them. The poor fella thought Gatland had said “45”, not “four to five”. That’s a lot of potassium in any man’s language.
And when coaching lets you down, you can usually rely on the coach driver. That’s what Kevin Keegan seemed to be getting at in March 2008 after his Newcastle United side lost 3-0 to Liverpool. “We’re still in charge of our own destination,” Wor Kev said confidently, and sure enough, there’s no record of the Geordies getting lost en route to any of their games that season.