Winning isn’t everything

Castlebar Mitchels' Ger McDonagh coaches a national school football team.placeholder image
Castlebar Mitchels' Ger McDonagh coaches a national school football team.

Two underage GAA coaches have their say on competition debate

PERSONAL experience is often a great learning tool.

So when well-known footballers and schools coaches, Clodagh McManamon and Ger McDonagh, spoke with The Mayo News recently they recalled underage days when a myriad of football adventures stretched in front of them.

Ger is a teacher in St Peter’s National School Snugboro and recently coached the girls team to the county Cuman na mBunscol final. Clodagh is a teacher in Sacred Heart School, Westport and heavily involved with the sports teams there.

These days, both of them are immersed in their own personal football campaigns but are also acutely aware of the discussion revolving around the competitive nature of Under-12 football. In ladies football the age-group is part of the calendar, with inter-club competitions at all levels, while boys at the same age play in matches where the scores and results are not recorded.

Clodagh, who is an established member of the Mayo senior squad, was in the colours of her native Burrishoole club at Under-12 and Under-14 before lack of numbers saw herself, her twin sister Ciara and Leona Ryder moving to Castlebar Mitchels for the rest of their underage days. They subsequently returned to Burrishoole to play adult football.

“When we were playing Under-12 with Burrishoole we never won a thing, but I don’t remember the focus ever being on winning,” she told The Mayo News.

“I remember the craic we had on the bus on the way to matches and the fun we had at training and games. All of my friends played football and many of them definitely weren’t there to win games, they were there to have fun, spend time outdoors with their friends and have the craic.

“My dad (Séamus), was our manager in those years and he just made sure we all enjoyed it. “He was a great coach and made sure everyone got a game. Some girls were happy enough to sit on the sideline, but he always encouraged them to play as well.

“Of course we would have loved to have won silverware together but the most important thing for us was the enjoyment element.”

Ger McDonagh had underage success with Castlebar Mitchels, but before he started playing with the club he was immersed in Cumann na mBunscol fare with Scoil Raifteiri in the town where the results weren't always positive.

“We were hockeyed by St Pat's and Breaffy every year when I was in third, fourth, fifth and sixth. We'd be walking up the road to St Pat's for a game, hoping they'd put the second team out against us. It was often a cricket score but we stuck at it because we loved playing football.”

McDonagh coached Snugboro NS to the Cumann na mBunscol final recently and is a fervent believer that the competition should retain its competitive edge while also developing another non-competitive side.

“There should to be two elements to Cumann na mBunscol,” said the teacher.

“There needs to be a development side of it where everyone gets to play in a Go-Games style and there’s no score kept. This would be hugely important for the development of the game going forward.

“However, there certainly needs to be a competitive element too. The current Cumann na mBunscol competitions are hugely important for the players and the development of the game itself.”

McManamon is equally assertive when the question of Cumann na mBunscol and Under-12 football is raised, but warns that creating the correct environment is vitally important.​

“I think having competitive football at Under-12 level is good because girls and boys then realise that winning and losing games isn’t the be-all-and-end-all. The focus should mainly be on taking part and making sure all players are catered for at that age, but the only way that will happen is if all clubs are on the same page and that’s very difficult to enforce.

“Cumann na mBunscol is a great competition and I’ve many happy memories of playing with Newport NS,” she added. “We won the West Mayo final one year up in Kilmeena and that was just brilliant. We didn’t go on to win the county final that year, but I can’t remember whatever game we lost, so it obviously had no negative impact.

“However, it's crucial that the coach creates the right environment of participation and fun. “Winning and losing a football match at that age isn't the most important thing in the world and we have to remember that.”

Ger McDonagh agreed wholeheartedly with that statement.

“Raising the awareness of coaches and parents is critical. Of course everyone loves to win but we must ask ourselves what are we trying to achieve here? Player development and participation should be valued more than anything else,” he added before McManamon had the final word.​

“It wasn’t until I started playing with Castlebar Mitchels at Under-16 level that I experienced winning with a club team, and the first time I played with Mayo was with the minors, aged 17. So all I remember from U-12 football is the craic and the fun we had. I don’t remember ever focusing on winning and I liked it that way at that age.”




Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice