Where do we go from here?


KEVIN McSTAY This week I could produce a very straightforward, ‘easy to write-easier to read’ 900-word column on just why exactly Mayo lost the All-Ireland quarter-final to Meath last Sunday.


THIS week I could produce a very straightforward, ‘easy to write-easier to read’ 900-word column on just why exactly Mayo lost the All-Ireland quarter-final last Sunday. Some of you would agree with my analysis while others might argue I’ve missed the point, yet again.
So, I’m going to try something different. Try to give a sense of the lack of hope many in the county have today. It’s absolutely not a shot at anybody in the squad or associated with football in the county, it’s just how I feel about it this morning. I imagine many/most of you will be able to empathise with various aspects of where we stand this week.
There was a time when this county had reason to hope when the county team set sail for Croke Park. The Liam O’Neill/John O’Mahony teams of the 80s seemed to have an affinity with their public, a sense of belief in what they were trying to do.
At least that’s my memory of it. Of course that side was ultimately unsuccessful but that is not the point. The journey was always in hope. John Maughan’s team of 1996 to perhaps 1999 embraced that same sense of purpose but after that the trail has gone cold.
At least that’s how it feels to me. While the current squad that has played in two finals in this new decade is as ‘successful’ as any of the recent groupings, I just find it so hard to identify with their efforts. I suppose that is unfair of me, but that’s how it feels to me.
In fact, the current management can argue there are parts of this team relatively new to senior football and they are right: Donal Vaughan, Ger Cafferkey, Trevor Howley, Aidan O’Shea and a few others. But, there are almost a dozen of the players associated with the 2004 and 2006 drubbings still around the scene. Many of them young men. But, many of them scarred from the experience of those years. And the presence of those players and their association with the defeats seems to taint the whole squad with the idea of damaged goods. Which is probably unfair but that’s how it feels to me.
When I ask my colleagues on The Sunday Game team to pick the Mayo players they would like to have on their team, Alan Dillon is always the only one to make the cut.
So, if we accept that any All-Ireland winning team must have a handful of outstanding players, where does that leave us with our sole representative? Certainly, a long taxi ride short of winning All-Irelands in Croke Park. So, how did we think we were different this year?
And if we accept the above, and I think we must, then here’s another question: do we constantly over-rate our footballers? Last week recall that many in Mayo felt this was a new Mayo team and things were being done differently.
This week ask yourself who played well for Mayo against Meath last weekend and the only sane answer will include Aidan O’Shea (a teenager waiting for his Leaving Certificate results) and Aidan Kilcoyne. Both had to retire injured but not before they made a real impression on the Meath defence. But folks, that’s as good as it got!
When we started the selection process for Man-of-the-Match on The Sunday Game last weekend, not a single Mayo player got more than 20 seconds consideration. Indeed, all 15 plus the substitutes used might reflect on their performance and come to the conclusion they could have done a lot more.
Just contrast the Mayo effort post the teenager’s goal and the Meath effort when the match was there for plucking in the dying minutes. In the first instance Meath closed the four-point gap in a mere four minutes while in the second, Meath added five quick points in succession in the space of five minutes. Ball burst, game over.
I wish I had the answers but I don’t. I have no doubt John O’Mahony was sure he had the team in a good place and yet, this morning we are in the same dark room Dublin find themselves. Not so much beaten, but surprised, shocked, and on the rocks to a certain degree. The plan is in ribbons and nobody is sure where to go from here.
At least the news JOM wants to stay at it must be viewed as a positive. My own sense of his declaration is that he is an extremely busy man that must see something in enough of these players to carry on. And in the absence of any other option or perhaps even hope, it is best if that happens. I continue to wish him well.
WILL things change any day soon? There is an early evening period when The Sunday Game team takes a time-out to gather their thoughts for the night-time show ahead. It might be a corner of the office, a stroll around Donnybrook or a trip to the canteen. Last Sunday night I spent my break with Clare’s colourful manager Ger Loughnane. And I know when he looks at me he sees the plight of the Mayo man and understands instantly the dilemma of the Mayo man.
He knows you want to pack it all in and forget about Mayo football success and just play bloody golf or something. But you can’t. And if you feel like that as a supporter, try what it must be like for the footballers that are having a few beers today trying to dull the pain.
As Ger put it: ‘Until you put up, you must shut up’ and this is so true. He should know. He spent all his teenage and adult playing years getting the hits but never the cups. And until his Clare team changed the way his county was perceived, they had to endure the barbs.
See, those that win can pontificate all they want because that’s the way it is. The winners have always written the history books. They tell us that Liam McHale and his buddies from ’96 should shut up and get on with things, build a bridge and all that. Maybe they are right. But that advice comes from the winner’s camp and it’s easy to come to those conclusions when the medals are in your house.
What about the match then? Is there anything to say about it? Well, Meath were the most deserving of winners, as ever maximising their talent for the sake of the team, hanging in there when all looked lost and knowing what to do when the winning opportunity presented.
I really admired this Meath performance; they are no world-beaters but they gave everything they had for the jersey. Alas, our boys never convinced me it really meant enough, that winning this match was crucial for their well-being as a team and as a group.
At least that’s the way it felt to me. And I know that is probably unfair because the players wanted to do things differently.
But that’s the way it felt.