The times, they are a-changin’


GAA The GAA is regarded in some quarters of Irish society as a deeply conservative organisation. But according to Professor Gearóid Ó Tuathaigh, the opposite is true.
Dublin
THE GAA is regarded in some quarters of Irish society as a deeply conservative organisation. But according to Professor Gearóid Ó Tuathaigh, the opposite is true. One of the key factors behind the Association’s many achievements, he told an audience last Tuesday, is that ‘it has shown again and again its adaptability for change’.
Professor Ó Tuathaigh was delivering a lecture entitled ‘The GAA at 125: The Challenge of Change’ to the Dublin branch of the NUI, Galway Alumni Association in the Davenport Hotel in Merrion Square.
The Limerick native, a ‘lifelong’ GAA member, detailed the Association’s central role in Irish sporting culture. He pointed to ESRI figures which showed that 60 per cent of all attendees at sports fixtures were people who went to GAA matches. On the debit side, he noted that the GAA’s de facto nationalist position had produced ‘losses’, and that hurling – a major passion of his – had failed to extend ‘beyond its heartland’.
Noting that the GAA had survived the Parnell split, the Civil War, the division of the 1930s, the Emergency, and the ravage of emigration visible in PJ Gilmore’s video footage during the 1950s, Professor Ó Tuathaigh said the Association had repeatedly displayed an ability to change. He added that while it was ‘easy to ridicule the … expert who knows the Treoir Oifigúil back to front’, the GAA at local level had been ‘remarkably well served’ by honest, dedicated and wholesome leadership.
Unlike many other Irish organisations, the NUI, Galway history professor noted, the GAA ‘never suffered a lasting, enduring split’. As events evolved in Northern Ireland, the Association was willing to adapt rather than ‘die in the last ditch’. Though it’s regarded by some as full of unstinting purists, he said, the GAA ‘has been at the front of the wave of major changes in Ireland’, in how it embraced planning, the mass media, and finance.
On the challenges facing the GAA, the speaker focused first on globalisation and the competition provided by other sports. International rules offered an outlet for elite players, he said, but were unlikely to be a key determinant for players making choices about what game they would play. GAA Director-General Páraic Duffy, who gave the closing address, agreed with this assessment, though he noted ‘a strange element’ in the GAA – ‘fanatical Manchester United fans who are anti-soccer!’
Professor Ó Tuathaigh said that ‘the inherent attractiveness of the games’ meant that with shrewd marketing, Gaelic sports could become a niche leisure activity among people with no Irish background. If Comhaltas Ceoltóirí Éireann can do it with traditional music, he suggested, so can the GAA!
On professionalism, he said that holding the line at ‘no pay for play’ was defensible, but ‘not enough’ in light of lurid rumours of attractive packages being paid to managers. Páraic Duffy agreed that under-the-counter payments to managers was difficult to tackle – ‘people will not put their head on the block’ to expose this issue, he said.
Professor Ó Tuathaigh added that the GAA needs to examine where – ‘in management and other areas’ – women can play more prominent roles within the Association. And he echoed the DG’s recent prediction that the GAA’s difficulties in city areas means that ground-sharing with other sports may become inevitable.
He suggested that the Association had ‘reason to feel somewhat aggrieved’ at the failure in recent times of rugby schools to provide Gaelic games which, he said, raised questions about tradition, social prejudice, and residual snobbery. But he noted that the GAA’s role in universities has given the Association ‘access to expertise’ in a range of areas.
Páraic Duffy described as ‘absolutely ludicrous’ the idea put forward by some inter-county managers that the Sigerson and Fitzgibbon Cup finals be held before Christmas. And asked (by Shane McGrath of the Irish Daily Mail, formerly of this parish) about tension between clubs and counties, the DG said: “Clubs want to play their best players in all matches, and we have to break that.” Are ‘starred’ league matches on the way back, I wonder?