COLUMN: Edeh a good signing, but is he a big enough name for Mayo FC?

Ballyheane player Ben Edeh will join Mayo FC on July 1. Pics: John Corless/Sportsfileplaceholder image
Ballyheane player Ben Edeh will join Mayo FC on July 1. Pics: John Corless/Sportsfile

Edeh signs with the club as they gear up for their first season in the League of Ireland National League

THIS week, Mayo FC announced Ben Edeh as their first signing for their senior men’s National League team, for the campaign which starts in September.

This announcement comes on the back of the recent appointment of Anthony O’Neill as manager – a job which was advertised, drew over 20 applications, but he was always going to get.

The club then invited expressions of interest from prospective players, and anyone who had played in the Men’s U-20 League of Ireland, or the top tier of their own junior league, which in the Mayo case would be The Super League, or had played in the Inter-League Oscar Traynor Cup competitions, was eligible to apply.

Strangely the club didn’t extend the offer to players who might not qualify under these criteria, but had played in the Men’s Airtricity League of Ireland. Maybe this was an administrative omission or maybe not, but surely some ex-League of Ireland players would be ideal for the fledgling outfit.

In any event, The Mayo News understands that over 100 prospective players applied and a number were invited to trials or assessments, in Umbro Park in recent weeks.

RAISING QUESTIONS

One of these is Ben Edeh, currently on the books of Ballyheane FC.

Ben is a forward, who has shown flashes of brilliance for Ballyheane, but has never reached the performance at club level, that he achieved for the Mayo Inter League side, when he scored three goals in a dazzling performance, for the county team in Galway, in October 2023.

Ben is one of the Ballyheane Three, currently suspended by the Mayo League from playing in the Oscar Traynor Cup due to one of the club versus league rows that the local game is famous for.

But Mayo FC is different to the Mayo League, and Ben will be eligible to play for the club, when the registration window opens again, on July 1.

Ben’s announcement raises three questions.

Firstly, who else does Mayo FC hope to sign, secondly, is Ben a big-enough name to be highlighted as the first to sign for the club, and thirdly, where does this signing fit in the ‘poaching of players’ landscape, which surfaced recently between Mayo FC and the Youths League?

TALKS TAKING PLACE

Taking the first two questions together, it is believed that Mayo FC is in talks with a midfielder with Galway Hibs, whom Anthony O’Neill would know from his connections with Galway football, where he resides, and where he has worked.

The player is an ex-Galway United Academy player, and O’Neill managed in the Galway academy for a while.

The club is also expected to pursue Noe Baba currently on the books of Athlone Town who also played for Finn Harps and Waterford.

At 29, the central midfielder, who is well-known in the county, has age on his side and plenty of experience. And he’s a Mayo man.

And there are loads of other Mayo-born players currently on the books of League of Ireland clubs, enjoying varying levels of success.

Another prospect seems to be Regan Donelan who played for Galway United as recent as last season. He is currently on the books of Dunmore Town, playing in the Galway League.

Would Donelan or Baba not be bigger names to put in lights as their initial, marquee signing? This isn’t intended as a criticism of Edeh, who is big and strong and has ferocious pace, but his profile is not high, nationally.

If Mayo FC wants to attract players who will make the team competitive in the league, and or, attract sponsors, surely the biggest name you can get your hands on, should be the one to lead that charge?

OTHER NAMES

THERE are ex-League of Ireland players currently playing in the Mayo League too. David Cawley and Jesse Devers are with Ballina Town, Ryan Connolly with Ballyglass, and Martin Deady of Crossmolina, are a few to come to mind.

Glenhest Rovers target man, Connor McCarthy played at a high level too, in the UK. Cawley is the most on-form of these at the moment. Whether any would be interested in going back into all that, or if O’Neill would consider them, is another matter.

And what of other Mayo Super League players?

The Mayo News understands that a number of Mayo-based players, who meet the eligibility criteria, completed the expression of interest process and attended trials, but these didn’t include the classy Westport defender, Cillian White, or Castlebar Celtic attacking full-back, Mark Cunningham or tenacious midfielder Johnny Cocozza, who are all surely worthy of consideration.

There are others too, but we’ll leave it at those three for now.

POACHING VIEWS

The third question, that of potential ‘poaching’, doesn’t seem to have surfaced yet, but it is difficult to see what the club is doing in relation to the men’s team, being much different to the practice at academy level which has irritated clubs and drawn the wrath of the Mayo Youths League.

And what of Edeh himself? He’s still eligible to turn-out for Ballyheane until July 1, when he presumably officially signs for Mayo, but will he want to play and risk injury, or will he want to play, to sharpen himself up, considering he has played only one game so far this season, back in January?

What is the view in Ballyheane? And how will other clubs react, if Mayo FC flutters its eyelashes at their star players?

Will they throw a tantrum, or will they tacitly approve the approach the way they have on many occasions when the call came from other League of Ireland clubs?

The difficulties experienced on the pitch so far this season, by Mayo FC’s Under-20s, also manager by O’Neill, highlights the high standard existing in other clubs when you step into national competitions, and the importance of skill, physicality, speed and experience along with the undoubted coaching nous that O’Neill brings.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice