First impressions are predictable

placeholder image

It was the year’s opener, a first outing, a getting-to-know-you selection and, therefore, a skeletal Mayo. But for selectors it was scarcely informative. NUIG dominated the game.

First impressions are predictable

Hard not to look back in angerplaceholder image
Hard not to look back in anger

A fitter, more settled university was to be expected at Dangan as they prepare assiduously for Sigerson competition, but they will have learned little about their own worth from an encounter they dominated for most of the hour.

Mayo had six — David Clarke, Peadar Gardiner, Pat Harte, Aidan Kilcoyne, Alan Dillon and Billy Padden — of the team beaten in their last game of the championship by Tyrone. Other than the occasional burst none reached his normal standard. But you gain comfort in knowing that the likes of Dillon (who had twelve competitive appearances for the county last year) will improve as the season progresses.

The performance of Ger Cafferkey at full-back for the students was the one pencil of light shining through Mayo’s defeat. The Ballina man operated efficiently and confidently, and barring injury will surely start for Mayo in the Allianz League next month.

Castlebar’s Padraig Healy at corner back for NUIG also earned his place with a display equal to anything served up by a Mayo defence that suffered the indignity of conceding a goal in the opening seconds of the game.

Confusion in the full-back line about who was marking who could only have been the reason why Cathal McHugh was left unguarded as the ball from Kieran Conroy came floating in behind the defence. The finishing touch was a mere formality for the Roscommon man.

Ever after, Mayo were chasing the game with little evidence that they would catch up. For a while in the first half they had a greater share of the play, but not the power to press home that advantage. They were sluggish, and lacked leadership.

Peadar Gardiner made his own little piece of history when yellow-carded under the new experimental rules, the first Mayo man to experience dismissal for some rather insignificant misdemeanour. Three NUIG players were also banished to the line for similarly trivial transgressions, the first, Greg Begley, as early as the 9th minute.

And Charlestown’s David Caffrey, who replaced Gardiner also suffered a similar fate.

Under the new rules, each was replaced, but the fouls they committed would in ordinary circumstances have scarcely raised a murmur of dissent from any quarter — even from the victims.

Further assessment is necessary, however, before casting final judgment on the new regulations. Like all new rules, they must be given time to bed in to provide young players, as hoped, with a fairer chance of putting their skills into practice.

After conceding that goal, Mayo injected their play with a bit of fervour, but they overused the ball and as a result missed opportunities to take their points.

You would expect more return from a half-forward line made up of Aidan Kilcoyne, Alan Dillon and Billy Joe Padden. The sum of their contribution, however, came to three points, two from frees by Kilcoyne and one by Dillon.

Of course Dillon added much more in terms of work, and Padden had a good opening half. Their failure to keep up with the pace in the second half may have something to do with a heavy programme of weight training throughout the winter.

Nor did Pat Harte or Barry Kelly operate at midfield with the effect you would expect. The key man in this sector was Galway star Gareth Bradshaw more for his work rate than for any spectacular fielding.

Harte made the occasional foray into the students’ defence, but failure to part with the ball before running into cover — a characteristic prevalent in Mayo football — ruined budding opportunities for scores.

Kelly lacked the intensity associated with his performances for Ballaghaderreen which may again be due to weight training. But his midfield flair was evident on occasions. One lovely ray of vision from Dillon when he picked out the Ballagh’ man with a cross from the sideline was worth more than a point.

Austin O’Malley returned with a bit more fight in his soul, but he would benefit more from quicker delivery and a more direct approach to the goal. Too much dallying with the ball allows defences to organise themselves.

Minor star Aidan O’Shea was given a run at full-forward, and while he faced the impervious Ger Cafferkey, the future of Mayo football lies with the likes of O’Shea who has the strength and ability to compete with the best even though still in his teens.

Kiltane’s Mikey Sweeney seemed the most likely forward to score for Mayo. He was the liveliest forward around the goal and it was no surprise when the corner forward did eventually get the ball into the net.

It was Pat Kelly (who started well at centre-half back but failed to maintain that pace) ­ who set up the opportunity. On one of his trade-mark gallops through the centre, Kelly had split the defence sufficiently wide to take a point. Like others, he carried the ball too far, ran out of space and then hurled an uncontrolled pass low in towards the goal. Sweeney was first to get to the ball and made best use of it.

The half-back line of Peadar Gardiner, Pat Kelly and Colm Boyle were good on the offensive, especially in the first half. Their defence in general however, became more suspect as the game progressed.

Corner forward Conor Devaney scored 1-3 for NUIG and McHugh in the other corner 1-1. They, together with substitute John Connellan, found little difficulty in getting round Mayo’s full-backline.

For their second goal Devanney was able to worm his way up to the left corner, and in along the end line before crashing the ball to the net. It was too easy and the full-back line was vulnerable to the twists and turns of these three in particular.  While working hard individually, Colm Cafferkey, Stephen Drake and Kevin Keane, and substitute Sean Prendergast, did not have the dovetail experience of a backline used to one another’s play.

You can’t expect too much from an experimental side. But if you were looking for a catalyst for Mayo football he was not obvious. Next Sunday they travel to Ballinode for their annual combat with Sligo IT which they lost last year by six points. Further trials will be undertaken, new personnel on view.

Based on last Sunday’s results Roscommon are the form side. They walloped Sligo IT, and appear to be already benefiting from the appointment of Fergal O¹Donnell as manager. Their 17-point win has set alarm bells ringing around the province. Have we been too complacent about a Mayo-Galway Connacht final?

We’ll have a better idea of the merit of Roscommon’s win when Mayo meet the Sligo students on Sunday.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice