A lifetime of memories


Ninety-four-year-old Tom McNicholas, the last surviving member of Mayo’s All-Ireland-winning panel of 1936, takes a stroll down memory lane with Seán Rice.
The last man standing from 1936
Tommy McNicolas
TOM MCNICHOLAS is the last remaining link with Mayo’s first all-conquering senior team. Nothing about him betrays his years. He walks smartly; he drives his car; he retains a razor sharp intellect and, as a hobby, he deals in old, rare books.
He is 94 years of age.
His longevity sparkles not only with football success but also with academic achievement. For Tom, a retired schools inspector, also had a hand in the transformation of primary education in Ireland.
He missed playing in the All-Ireland final of 1936 because his new teaching post ruled out time off for collective training. The ensuing high profile enjoyed by Moclair and Munnelly and Kenny skirted him somewhat, but that final was the only match the Kiltimagh man missed in that championship.
“I was on the bench for the final. It would have been great to be on the team, but at the same time I was on the panel. I played mostly in the backs, but in the semi-final I played at centre-half forward on Miko Doyle of Kerry.”
His rise to the top was meteoric. Tom had never kicked a football when he arrived in St Nathy’s College in 1928. Five years later he was on the Mayo senior team. “Mine was only a rural national school with a small playground. You never saw a football. All you had was a rag ball.”
In Nathy’s he took to football ‘like a duck to water’ He showed promise in the first year because he was active and had a good pair of hands. In his second year he made the subs, but Nathy’s never won anything because of the opposition St Jarlath’s always presented.
Born in Treenagleeragh, Kiltimagh, on August 15, 1914, at the outbreak of the Great War, Tom was third in a family of ten. His nephew Anthony, who accompanied him to this interview, lives in the old family home.
Tom won a five-year scholarship to St Nathy’s, after which he trained as a teacher at St Patrick¹s Drumcondra, qualifying two years later. In college he developed his football skills with Erins’s Hope and other teams. In 1933 he had his first run with Mayo and went on to win four National League medals with the county. He toured America with them in 1937.
“The outstanding player of that time was Henry Kenny. He was the idol and the doyen of the team. And of course he had a wonderful man beside him, Patsy Flannelly. Patsy had speed but not the control of the ball that Henry had. But he was very light on his feet and terribly strong.”
It was a team, he said, that should have won three or four titles. Why they did not he can’t explain other than that they did not hit form on the day. They almost always managed to beat Galway and Roscommon. The problems generally arose in the semi-finals.
On the evening of their All-Ireland win Tom caught a bus back to Ballyjamesduff where he was teaching. “There was not the same hype about winning then even though you had big crowds, and you had the Nally Stand and the old Hogan Stand. Today it is nearly frightening going into Croke Park. I could understand a lot of people coming in being stage struck … unless you are a Kerry person and so used to it.”
Play was different, too. “In our day mainly you caught the ball and kicked it. Nowadays it is more basketball. I like this passing alright, but sometimes I think a lot of it is negative — going backward instead of forward. But when they are going forward there’s lovely movement I must admit. The speed of play has been upped, upped, upped.”
Another difference is that the football was made of leather and on a wet day it became very heavy.
Having graduated from St Patrick’s, Tom got a sub-shift at Cambrack School near his home in Treenagleeragh. For six months he walked the ten-mile round trip to school.
While there he applied for the post of assistant teacher in Ballyjamesduff. In his application he added that he was a member of the Mayo football team.
The administrator to whom he applied was an academic with little interest in football.
But the curate, Fr Joe Brady, a football enthusiast, was going through the applications, and on coming across Tom’s said to the administrator: ‘that’s your man’. “Afterwards the administrator got so fond of me that he would do anything I asked. I happened to be a very successful teacher and everything went well.”
Tom won a county junior championship medal with Ballyjamesduff, and a senior championship with Mount Nugent in Cavan. Anthony’s brother, Jim, who was also teaching in Cavan, played with Mullahoran, a senior side.
After seven years in the post during which time he also managed to attend week-end lectures at UCG graduating with a degree, Tom took up a new job in St Peter’s in Phibsborough.
No sooner had he settled than an offer of a principalship in Lisduff arrived from the parish priest in Kiltimagh. He could not take up the offer but at the request of the parish priest his brother Jim took it on. ‘I was ever so pleased because he fitted in like a glove.’
Tom taught in Phibsboro until 1948 when he was appointed inspector of schools. He married a Kerry girl, Nuala Quinlan and they had six children; Mary, who accompanied him to this interview, Walter, twins Ann and Aoibhinn, and Claire, all born in County Roscommon where Tom was posted as schools inspector, all now living in Dublin. Nuala died seven years ago.
Referring to the aura of fear that was once associated with inspectors, Tom said it often suited teachers to create that fear. In the old days when teachers started off there was what was known as payment by result. Only if pupils passed their exams were teachers paid.
A good idea? “Well, it was and it wasn’t. In very many schools you would find a lot of pupils not able to make the right progress, particularly in mathematics. Padraig Pearse and others denounced that system and it was dropped around 1908. Conradh na Gaeilge also did a lot to end it. It was part of the cruelty that was there. If the pupils did not learn, teachers ‘bet’ it into them.”
Although the system was changed, corporal punishment continued in schools until it was abolished in the eighties by Minister John Boland. But the minister gave no advice on what should replace it. Tom was happy with its abolition but felt that maybe a school board would have a certain amount of power in that regard.
After six years in Boyle, a stint in Clonmel and, on promotion to divisional inspector, a while in Limerick, Tom was appointed chairman of one of the committees set up by the department to draw up a new curriculum for primary schools.
The introduction of that curriculum in 1972 commenced the great advance in education.
The old curriculum with minor adjustments had been in force since 1922, he said. The accent was on promotion of the Gaelic language. “Teachers were encouraged to teach subjects through Irish when they were not able to do it in a way because a lot of them weren’t fluent enough. They did their best.”
But the authorities came to realise that they had to modify things, and the new curriculum was brought into force. In drawing it up, Tom and his team were anxious that it would be child-centred. “For the time that was in it, it was a bit too ambitious. Like everything it had to be tested and modified. But it has turned out to be very successful.
“The programme now in the primary school is so different to the time I started off, as different as chalk and cheese. There has been a wonderful change altogether.”
He retired in 1969 and his love of old books now exercises his mind. The older they are the more he likes them. Every two months he and some friends with a similar interest set up stall in Dublin. People come to browse and buy.
There is a worldwide interest in his collections. Professors contact him regularly. Dunsany is a great favourite of university professors in Japan. Another author they have a liking for is George Moore from Moorehall.
Tom also has a small circle of Irish speakers who come together an hour in the month, about a dozen of them, to converse and read in the native tongue.
To this interest in books largely he attributes his longevity. It keeps him thinking, keeps him active. He takes a drink but gave up smoking a long time ago. His wife was changing a nappy at the time while smoking. “Would you give them up,” he wondered. “I will if you will,” was her reply.
“I put my hand in my pocket, took out my box of cigarettes and threw it into the grate. She did the very same thing and the pair of us never smoked after that,” said Tom.
No indecision, no wavering, no excuses. Characteristics of the last of a rare breed of men who set a standard no team in this county or country has emulated in more than seventy years.