Black is the colour again

CRASH BALL It was the game which promised so much yet delivered so little. Many fans felt that this crop of Irish players were going to beat the magnificent All Blacks, but it was not to be.

Black is the colour again

CrashBall

Trevor Watson

IT was the game which promised so much yet delivered so little. Many fans and pundits around the country felt that this crop of Irish players were going to do what no other group had done in the past – defeat the magnificent All Blacks.

But it was not to be. We went gently into the Dublin night. We did not rage against the dying of the light. We were out-muscled, out-paced and out-played.

Even the Irish players who did show some sparks of brilliance (Wallace, Fitzgerald and O’Driscoll) took the gloss off that brilliance with some terrible errors such as missed tackles (Fitzgerald) and handling errors (O’Driscoll). Fitzgerald looked a little naïve at times, rushing too fast into tackles, but all in all he didn’t have a bad game, and was one of the players singled out afterwards by New Zealand coach Graham Henry for special praise.

It has often been said that the pivotal number ten jersey is the most important position on the field. It was painfully obvious last Saturday night that when O’Gara plays poorly, by extension, so do Ireland.

A kick blocked down with just seconds on the clock and two subsequent ‘slices’ into touch marked his first impression on the game in the early minutes. He looked quite clearly rattled. His marvellous penalty from near the halfway line aside, O’Gara had a terrible day at the office. It is a game he will want to forget as quickly as possible.

Dempsey was poor at the back with ball in hand – too much aimless kicking and offered little in terms of attacking pace. Conversely, his opposite number, Mills Muliaina, had possibly his finest hour in a black jersey. Whenever he got ball in hand his pace was electrifying and he made things happen.

Ditto with his midfield powerhouse Ma’a Nonu, who was this writer’s man of the match. The dreadlocked dynamo hurt Ireland every time he touched the ball, and his try was just reward for a fine performance.

Did Ireland coach Declan Kidney select the correct starting 15, or match-day 22 for that matter? Was Dempsey the man for full-back? Was Flannery the better option at hooker? Should there have been a place for a specialist number seven such as Jennings? Should there have been more adequate cover for the second row?

One suspects that Dempsey will nose out next Saturday with either Keith Earls or Rob Kearney slotting into the full-back berth. Or possibly even a recall for Murphy.

Flannery will start at hooker and there may be a reshuffle in the back row. The one thing about Kidney is that he was never afraid to make changes when at Munster (remember the Stringer/O’Leary drama last year?), so we must trust that he will make the necessary amendments for Saturday’s crucial clash with Argentina.

The outcome of the final game of the autumn series has more than just pride at stake – we must defeat Argentina if we wish to stay in the top eight of the IRB World rankings.

Should we drop below eighth, then we would be in the third seed pot for the draw for the next World Cup, meaning we would have one of the three Southern Hemisphere sides and possible also England or France to contend with. With only two teams coming out of each pool, that would be disastrous for our chances of making the knockout stages.

So Kidney must rally his troops for the next call to arms. We can not go gently into the night two weeks running. We must rage.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice