Andy Moran gives his verdict on penalty shoot-outs

Andy Moran was speaking ahead of the Electric Ireland Minor Championship Finals. Pic: Inpho.ieplaceholder image
Andy Moran was speaking ahead of the Electric Ireland Minor Championship Finals. Pic: Inpho.ie

The elation and devastation of spot-kick deciders

PENALTY shoot-outs may be a relatively new arrival in the GAA world, but former Mayo star Andy Moran, who has suffered more than most from the spot-kick lottery, believes they have now found their own niche in the sport.

Speaking to The Mayo News ahead of the upcoming Electric Ireland GAA All-Ireland Minor Championship finals, the Ballaghaderreen man said he was on the edge of his seat in Hastings Insurance MacHale Park when Mayo and Derry went head to head from the penalty spot. 

"Traditionally penalties aren't the way to finish games, but I would argue that we need to make a spectacle as well. Of course, we need to keep the traditions of our game in place, but on Saturday evening the two kids and Jenny and myself were on the edge of our seats in Castlebar.

"I do think we have to make a spectacle for our supporters and our product. I don't fully agree with penalties but the tension in the crowd at the end of the game on Saturday was spectacular and as Mayo people we were just unfortunate to come out on the wrong side of it," the current Leitrim manager added.

The condensed championship season means that replays no loner occur and when games finish level after extra time the winning team is the one emerging victorious from the penalty shoot-out.

"In my first year with Leitrim we lost a penalty shoot-out to Sligo. In my second year we famously lost to New York and this year we were practising them coming into the latter stages of the Tailtean Cup," Moran explained.

"In New York we had the exact five lads you'd hand-pick to take the penalties and we didn't score any of them, so it's a game of composure and the team who have won a few (shoot-outs) show that when the pressure comes on. Derry, who have won a few of them already showed that composure on Saturday evening.

"If you see the pressure Cillian O'Connor put on McGuigan when he walked up and stuck the first penalty in the top corner. I was thinking 'Shane McGuigan has to feel the pressure of that,' but he just goes up and bangs it in. It was a great test of his mettle and courage. There was great skill and composure to put the ball in the corner. He hasn't been playing his best football and then to go in after Cillian O'Connor puts the ball in the top corner and to kick his penalty the way he did takes great skill.”

A lengthy interview with Andy Moran will be carried in Tuesday’s Mayo News

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice