‘Alternative facts’ in the GAA
FOOTBALL Much of the commentary around Mayo this season has been wide of the mark, writes Ciaran O’Hara
Opinion
Ciaran O’Hara
IF you search hard enough in second-hand book stores, or perhaps online, you may chance upon a copy of the book ‘Over The Bar’, by the great journalist and broadcaster BreandΡn Ó hEithir.
Written to coincide with the centenary of the GAA, it’s a personalised account of his love affair with our national games. Ó hEithir grew up in the Aran Islands, where the GAA at that time had no formal presence, but a love of the GAA was passed down to him from his father, and it stayed with him all his life.
The book finishes with the story of Private Bill Doonan from Cavan, who while based in Monte Casino during the Second World War was marked absent without leave one Sunday afternoon. A search was mounted to find Doonan, his unit’s radio operator, and after many hours he was discovered up a tree, where somehow, he had managed to get a signal from the All-Ireland final between Cavan and Roscommon. Avoiding court martial, Doonan later went on to win two All Irelands, but as Ó hEithir put it at the time: “If anyone ever asks you what the GAA is all about just think of Bill Doonan, the wanderer, on the side of that hill, in the middle of a World War ... at home”.
What brought Ó hEithir – and Bill Doonan – to mind this week was the sheer volume of stories, rumours, columns and opinions I’ve encountered about the current Mayo team in the last six months. If Bill Doonan were in Monte Casino today, he could fill his boots with GAA, and would need no recourse to a tree or the army’s prized radio; a smartphone would suffice.
And that’s a reflection of how much things have changed in such a relatively short timespan. In 1989, Ó hEithir was living in Paris and came home only to write about the All-Ireland finals. His columns were always measured, fair and accurate, because The Irish Times was in competition only in real terms with the Irish Independent, the Irish Press (Google it, children) and the Cork Examiner.
Ó hEithir didn’t need to shout loudest to get people’s attention, he simply had to write well to get it. I still have the column he wrote on the Sunday of Mayo’s defeat to Cork in 1989, I kept it with a purpose, as he’d vexed my 13-year old self. You see, Ó hEithir wasn’t just a writer or a broadcaster to me. Even then he was a hero, but one who was in my orbit as distinctly as Willie Joe Padden was.
Ó hEithir was a family friend. Growing up I was used to him arriving out of the blue, wherever we lived. And oh, the stories he could tell, the places he’d been, the people he’d met and the colour with which he could describe them. And so, I kept BreandΡn’s column to have it out with my friend, who dared to suggest that Cork had made hard work of beating Mayo. Back then, I was too partisan when it came to Mayo ... many would suggest I still am.
I never got to have that argument with Ó hEithir. He passed away before I saw him again. But his writing has been a constant in my life, and I re-read ‘Over The Bar’ two or three times a year. It has stood the test of time, and is still – 33 years after publication – the best GAA book of them all.
Exploding a few myths
WHAT has all this to do with the current Mayo team? Well, all the commentary of the last number of months about the Mayo team, has got me thinking what Ó hEithir would have made of the sheer explosion of the media. How would he have felt about outlets that place more value on controversy than on accuracy? How would he have felt about blogs that place expediency over civility? Most particularly, what would he have made of the unfiltered impact of social media or of clickbait?
Competition – outside of the boundaries of a pitch – is what has changed the GAA most of all since his passing, but particularly in the media. That is not true just of the GAA, but of society. We live in a world where truth is subjugated to ‘alternative facts’, where in the absence of real access, opinion fills a vacuum, and ultimately, people’s perceptions are altered by that opinion.
Let’s take some of that commentary and try to wrestle with what is fact and what is alternative fact. It is an actual fact that at various times this year, the Mayo team have struggled for form or consistency, and in many quarters that is presented as evidence that this team’s summit lies behind, rather than before them.
But who are we ultimately to make any assertions about the team? We don’t know what’s been going on behind dressing-room doors, on the training field or in the gym. We don’t know what the strength and conditioning programme for the year is, or what game-plans are being tested in training, or who has an illness or a tear. We don’t know what is happening in the work-life of the players or management or in their personal lives ... all of this can affect performance too.
All we can know with any degree of certainty is that the players and back-room involved with Mayo want to and are trying to do well. Should we not, therefore, just judge each game on its individual merits? If the team has a scrappy win or a defeat, judge where they need to improve or where the opposition are successful, rather than making sweeping assertions that the end of this team’s world is nigh. It might not make be good clickbait, but at least it would be honest.
Many commentators suggest that seven years of success and high performance by this Mayo team has come at a physical cost to them, and that too much of that load has been carried by too few players. And yet, the same commentators suggest a Dublin team in their eighth successive year in this position are ready for an assault on the three-in-a-row.
Consider this as an actual fact: during the last seven years that Mayo have contested the All-Ireland semi-finals, 54 players have worn the green and red in championship. That’s quite a turnover by any measurement. Just 13 of the current panel played in the 2011 championship, and three of those are unlikely to start against Kerry. Compare that to Dublin – in the same timeframe, 46 players have lined out for the four-time All-Ireland champions, and yet few suggest that their load is carried by too few.
Most of the commentators making these assertions played in an era when the same care was not taken in terms of sports science, so how can they judge accurately when a team is finished? The current generation of players may actually be the guinea pigs for how long a team can go on with the right preparation.
Age seems to be another concern for the detractors. It seems they’ve forgotten how young the likes of Cillian O’Connor, Aidan O’Shea and Lee Keegan were when they first joined the Mayo panel. The core of the team is only really reaching their peak now. As for the older players, unquestionably some are not the players or the athletes they were. But how can it be acceptable to write Andy Moran or Keith Higgins off as the wrong side of 30, when the likes of Peter Stringer and Donncha O’Callaghan continue to play a far more attritional, professional sport into their late thirties?
Only real knowledge of how players train, recover and prepare can provide proof as to whether a player is still fit to contribute to a team. There is an adage that if you are good enough, you are old enough. You can flip that on its head and say that if you are good enough, you are young enough too. Ultimately, in the absence of knowledge of how the players and management look after each other, can we not confine commentary on their value to the side to their performances and to the character they have shown, particularly this year in such an elongated campaign? There is nothing like games to prepare a team, and this team have had plenty this year.
Rochford in the firing line
PROBABLY the most disappointing of all the alternative facts are those presented regarding Stephen Rochford. He volunteers his time, like so many others in the GAA. He has done so when few anywhere else would have. In his time in charge, it has seemed like it has been a case of ‘damned if you do and damned if you don’t’. He knew coming into the role that there would be pressure. He knew that to most media outlets, the team are box-office and therefore would be scrutinised to a much more forensic degree than perhaps any other team, with the probable exception of Dublin.
What he couldn’t have known is just how unfair some in the media can be. In recent weeks he has been presented as someone who coaches by algorithm rather than intuition, as someone who is bossed about by and too close to his players, and – in some quarters – as being out of his depth. He, his family and his friends have maintained a quiet dignity throughout what can only be described as character assassination.
So, let’s look at the real facts – Stephen Rochford’s record as Mayo manager is already comparable to those of John O’Mahony, John Maughan, Mickey Moran and James Horan, because like all those men, he has led Mayo to an All-Ireland final. He did this, by the way, with a team that are over the hill/out of control/self-destructive/playing O’Shea out of position/lacking a marquee forward/defensively naïve, etc, etc (insert cliché here).
It’s time for some perspective. In any other era, he would have been hailed as a Mayo messiah, but familiarity has bred contempt among some commentators. They would sooner see anyone other than Mayo on the horizon again, and so they peddle contradictions rather than asking why he has been so successful in getting the team to an All-Ireland final (which Mayo lost by a point) and the subsequent All-Ireland semi-final.
On the one hand, Stephen has been criticised for being too conservative, and then ridiculed for being too brave, in changing the goalkeeper in last year’s All-Ireland final replay. He has been lauded for outfoxing Mickey Harte in one quarter-final and taken apart for being outsmarted by Kevin McStay in another.
We’re told he’s introduced none of the All-Ireland-winning under-21 team. Yet Fergal Boland, Conor Loftus and Stephen Coen have featured prominently this year, joining the already established Diarmuid O’Connor, while a host of other under-21s have been tried out in the last 20 months.
It should never simply be a case of change for change’s sake in any team. The under-21s must dislodge some of the best footballers in the county’s history and earn their starting positions. When they do that, they’ll emerge as much more rounded and better footballers for having to do so.
There have been times as the repeated attacks on Stephen Rochford were made that you wished he would come out and defend himself, explain the real rationale behind the substitutions that people were questioning, or quashing some of the ridiculous rumours which now seem to emerge in every county. To his credit, though, he has held his counsel. It’s been Mourinho-esque to some degree, as the manager takes the heat and the pressure for his players.
Probably the most damning criticism is that he has changed nothing in Mayo’s style of play … which is simply not true. If anything, he has appeared to have different plans for different opposition, and who says he must change anything in style of play if it comes to it? Management is about much more than selecting players and deciding on a style of play. It involves game management, tactical management, situational management, logistical management and personnel management. And yet, many will simply judge it on the grain of salt that tips the scales one way or the other. It would pay many better to judge how often the scales are balanced.
I’ll finish with some final facts. For the 21st time in seven years, Mayo will play a championship game in Croke Park this Sunday. That’s 12 more games than the team have played in McHale Park in the same period. The team have made the venue a second home, and the county’s record there is good, enough so that we should be confident of a performance on the day. Eleven wins, four draws and five defeats (three of those by a single point) says so. It’s time now to start judging this team on the merits of what it has achieved, rather than what it hasn’t ... and if that’s not good enough ,so be it.
But let’s not be swayed by alternative facts in judging what may well be the greatest Mayo team of all time.
* Ciaran O’Hara is a TV Producer and Director from Kiltane. He is the Executive Producer of Sky Sports GAA coverage.
* This article first ran in the printed edition of The Mayo News on Tuesday, August 15.