Woman (48) died of pneumonia at MUH


Solicitor claims Anne Marie O’Brien would have survived if she had received ‘a modicum of satisfactory treatment’
Anton McNulty
A MOTHER of four who died as a result of pneumonia would have survived and lived a long life if she had received medical intervention in Mayo University Hospital just days before her death, her inquest heard.
Anne Marie O’Brien (48) of Windsor, Castlebar, died in Mayo University Hospital on October 2, 2016, after she suffered a cardiac arrest in her home earlier that day. The postmortem found that she died as a result of pneumonia with a background of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.
The inquest into the death of Ms O’Brien opened yesterday (Monday) in Castlebar and heard that she attended the Emergency Department of Mayo University Hospital on September 24, 2016, suffering from severe back pain and was unable to walk.
Mr Damien Tansey, solicitor for the family of Ms O’Brien, claimed that there was a row that night in the hospital between two doctors over whether she should be admitted or not and she was eventually discharged at 4am on September 25.
Mr Tansey described the scenes that night as chaotic. He said Ms O’Brien again attended the Emergency Department on September 29, before being discharged on September 30 and brought home in a wheelchair by a taxi.
On October 2, she suffered a cardiac arrest in her home and was brought by ambulance to MUH. Attempts to resuscitate her were described as ‘futile’ and she was pronounced dead at 10.20pm. Mr Tansey told the Coroner for Mayo, Mr Patrick O’Connor that the family had no issue with attempts to save her life on October 2 but had issues with the care she was given from September 24 until her death.
The inquest heard that her C Reactive Protein (CRP) reading was at 183 when the normal range should be between zero and five. CRP is a blood test marker for inflammation in the body. Consultant Pathologist, Dr Tomas Nemeth agreed with Mr Tansey that the reading was ‘off the wall’ and that Ms O’Brien’s oxygen and haemoglobin levels also indicated that she was in trouble.
Dr Nemeth said it was his view that Ms O’Brien had very serious pneumonia in the days before she died but could not say for how long. “The postmortem showed that death was due to pneumonia,” Mr Tansey said. “Had she been admitted and put on antibiotics and fluids and given the appropriate treatment she would have survived without any difficulty. Had she received a modicum of satisfactory treatment we would not be here today.”
Mr Tansey claimed that when she was in hospital on September 29 and 30, none of the basic checks, such as the taking of blood pressure or a stethoscope test, were undertaken.
Mr Tansey said that statements from the doctors who attended to Ms O’Brien in the days prior to her death were not included in the inquest file. He made an application to have the inquest adjourned to seek statements from those doctors.
Mr O’Connor said he was agreeable to an adjournment on condition that Mr Tansey and Ms Sasha Gayer, senior counsel for the hospital, come to an agreement on which medical personnel should provide statements.
After a brief period of discussion, both parties agreed that six doctors will be asked to provide statements on Ms O’Brien’s care from September 24, until her death. Mr O’Connor adjourned the inquest until November 19 when he will hear evidence from the doctors and decide a verdict.
Mr Tansey also confirmed that civil proceedings were also being brought against the hospital by the family.