‘Why not?’ - Mayo TD floats idea of using AI to ‘teach’ weapons to obey international law


Fine Gael TD Keira Keogh spoke on the subject during a recent meeting of the Joint Committee on Artificial Intelligence
A Mayo TD has floated the idea of using artificial intelligence (AI) to ‘teach’ autonomous weapons to obey international law.
Fine Gael TD Keira Keogh spoke on the subject during a recent meeting of the Joint Committee on Artificial Intelligence.
Deputy Keogh said: “I 100 per cent agree that we should not allow machines to determine who lives or dies.
“I fully agree that machines cannot understand the true value of a human life because they are not themselves living beings. I wanted to start with the caveat that I agree with all of that.”
However, she went on to highlight the cruelty that humans are capable of.
“As a behavioural psychologist, I want to play devil's advocate, kind of.
“I will bring a totally different perspective, just to upset the conversation, by looking at what we have seen humans do across the ages in psychological tests but also in genocides and holocausts.
“According to reports from Vietnam, for example, we have seen that human judgment can be completely biased and fallible and in many ways can have catastrophic effects.”
Deputy Keogh then suggested that AI could be used to prevent some of the worst human behaviour.
“I wonder whether there is any hope that if we build in safety by design, autonomous weapons taught to obey international law will in some cases be better than human judgment.
“It is a very devil's advocate kind of question but history has shown us that humans will follow orders in some desperate circumstances. It is a very out-there question, but why not?”
In response, Harvard Law School lecturer Bonnie Docherty said Deputy Keogh raised a very valid question.
Ms Docherty said: “It is not an out-there question; it is a very valid one. I have a couple of responses.
“It is true that autonomous weapon systems would lack emotion and therefore lack the anger and - I will not say evil - the things that drive people to commit genocide or act in anger and kill people unnecessarily.
“At the same time they would lack the compassion that humans also possess, or that some humans possess, at least, and that studies have shown can serve as a check on killing. I always feel the lack of emotions counterbalances the opposite case.”
She went on to question whether AI could effectively obey and impose international law.
“As for them being taught to obey international law, there is the question of whether they can be, given that they lack human judgment and certain factors.
“I am not a roboticist but from what I hear from roboticists there are some serious challenges to that.
“Even if they were taught to obey international law, there are still other factors to deal with, such as the lack of accountability if there are gaps in compliance with international law.
“There are still the security risks in terms of upping the threshold to war. There remain the dignity concerns, which the Deputy is playing devil's advocate about so we can set those aside for the moment.”
Ms Docherty concluded by saying that such a system might create more problems than it would solve.
