When ‘Prime Time’ fails to investigate

Westport’s thorny Garden of Edenplaceholder image
Westport’s thorny Garden of Eden

The RTÉ Prime Time feature last Tuesday on FÁS schemes in Castlebar was a farce. To use taxpayers to pay for this is obscene.

When ‘Prime Time’ fails to investigate

DeFacto

Anyone involved with FÁS schemes is aware of the criteria for applications. A FÁS statement reads: “The Prime Time programme failed to inform viewers that all of the payments to schemes associated with Castlebar Social Services were used to fund participation in a wide range of activities. Meals on Wheels were only included to provide cover when there were absences of volunteers in the Meals on Wheels operation. This was necessary to ensure insurance cover was provided for participants on these courses…”

What the programme failed to state is that 93 per cent of all funding for schemes is spent on the workers’ wages, with seven per cent for training and materials. The programme chose to zone in on the Meals on Wheels application aspect, implying that funding was being sought for work that was not being carried out. This was a grossly unfair portrayal. It also left loose the implication that there was a question over exactly where the funds ended up. All FÁS scheme funds are audited annually, down to the final cent. This was not presented. The schemes highlighted in the programme provided services to local communities in and around Castlebar, the church, the parish centre, the Alzheimer Patient Care Unit, laundry for the elderly, a crèche, a Travellers’ pre-school, care-taking and maintenance of community centres and village enhancement.

In total 15 people from the parish schemes worked in the Meals on Wheels Centre at various stages, from food preparation to building repairs and maintenance. They even renovated two rooms that subsequently provided the centre with rental income. 

Back to the FÁS statement: “All sponsors, when applying for assistance from FÁS, are advised to include all work that they may wish to undertake to allow for changes depending on the capability of the participants. All FÁS funded Community Employment Projects are subject to a rigorous approvals process involving the social partners at local level. All FÁS-funded projects are subject to regular and on-going monitoring.”

While there were several schemes in operation over the years FÁS cut down on the number of schemes and asked various groups to amalgamate. This prompted new scheme applications.

Centre stage in the programme was former FÁS employee, Eddie Hoban. He is a current director and board member of two schemes working out of the Castlebar parish centre – one a FÁS community employment scheme, the other a Pobail social economy scheme. Eddie Hoban has been involved in parish schemes in Castlebar, on a voluntary basis, since his retirement from FÁS in 1996, 13 years ago.

Eddie Hoban had agreed to go on camera after he received a list of written questions. He wanted time to check the files to have the facts before him. The programme reporter asked questions not on the list, the details of which Eddie did not have to hand. The resultant scene was hard on Eddie Hoban. 

The late Canon Paddy Curran could not talk. That did not stop his name being raked in the mud. Paddy Curran was a strong individual but he was full of integrity and the implications made in the programme would have earned a legal response from the living.

The current scheme supervisors, Martin Lyons and TJ Kirrane, were not even afforded the courtesy of having part of their filmed contributions shown. Instead they were presented as two speechless side-kicks. Why did Prime Time not detail the work done by members of the scheme on Meals on Wheels? Why did it not detail the letter of October 2004 from the Chair of Social Services thanking the schemes for their work on Meals on Wheels? Why did it not state that investigations had already been carried on the schemes by FÁS, Pobal, Minister Éamon Ó Cuív’s department, the Archbishop of Tuam, the Public Accounts Committee and the Comptroller and Auditor General?  And the programme never mentioned the history of employee disquiet in the Social Services Centre with a successful constructive dismissal case and unfair dismissal case. Investigative journalism how are you!

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice