What do councillors do?
One depiction of the Irish councillor is of the ‘fixer’ – the first port of call for constituents when a problem arises.
“One depiction of the Irish councillor is of the ‘fixer’ – the first port of call for constituents when a problem arises at local level.”
Dr Mark Callanan
NEXT week, the electorate will be asked to pass judgement on the performance of their local councillors, yet many people are unaware of what councillors actually do. The electorate will choose a number of candidates to represent them on local councils around the country. Apart from TDs, MEPs and the President, local councillors are the only other office-holders in the state with a direct mandate from the electorate.
One depiction of the Irish councillor is of the ‘fixer’ – the first port of call for constituents when a problem arises at local level, raising issues of concern, writing letters and getting problems solved. Another way of looking at councillors is that after they have taken office, they become part of the board of directors of multi-million euro organisations providing a wide range of local services, from the fire brigade, public libraries, waste management services, roads and traffic, social housing, water supply, public parks, playgrounds, theatres, leisure facilities, and supporting local festivals.
There is no doubt that councillors have important responsibilities. Firstly, they can act as intermediaries between individuals and public services – in some cases responding to the needs of constituents for information, assisting people to access services, advising them on their options, etc. – the illustrative task of making sure the potholes at the end of Mrs Murphy’s road are filled comes to mind. A series of studies based on both interviews and surveys have shown that many councillors see this type of ‘constituency work’ as taking up most of their time, given that their performance in delivering on the needs of individual constituents is seen as the main means of electoral success.
Secondly, councillors are responsible for determining the policy framework for local councils across a range of services. For example, national legislation sometimes delegates powers to local councillors to adopt rules that apply in their area (known as ‘bye-laws’). These can affect everything from litter to parking and traffic management. The elected council also adopts the annual budget for the local authority, and therefore determines where money is spent in different areas.
Of course, the division of powers between councillors and staff is not nearly as neat in practice as it is on paper. For example, local councillors can often bring additional information to the attention of staff in operational matters, while local councillors often rely on local authority staff for advice on policy matters. While many councillors complain about the powers of county/ city managers in public, in practice there is usually a constructive working relationship between the council and the manager, at least on most issues.
In terms of the cohort of councillors currently in office, the average councillor in Ireland is male, self-employed, and over 45. Women are under-represented on local councils (though not to the same extent as they are in the Dáil), as are younger people and salaried employees. Perhaps reflecting the part-time nature of the role, the ranks of local councillors are dominated by those who have some flexibility over their work timetable (such as small businessmen, farmers or the retired).
One might ask whether a country the size of Ireland needs local councils at all? However, all countries large and small have elected local government, and international comparisons show that we have a relatively small number of local authorities in Ireland relative to our population. There can be a tendency in the national media to reduce local elections to simply being a mid-term referendum on the performance of the government parties of the day. While undoubtedly this may be true for some voters and is part of the picture, other voters may base their vote on their estimation of local candidates’ ability to carry out constituency work, or on local issues such as waste charges, the location of controversial facilities, or planning in rural areas.
Dr Mark Callanan lectures in local government studies at the Institute of Public Administration in Dublin, and is co-editor of ‘Local Government in Ireland: Inside Out’.