Planning appeal to approve 24-hour gym in west Mayo town fails


An Bord Pleanála refused planning permission to convert Westport warehouse into a 24-hour gym
AN appeal to overturn a decision by Mayo County Council to refuse planning permission for a 24-hour gym in Westport has failed.
Daniel Cooley of DM Fitness and Health had appealed a decision by Mayo County Council to refuse permission to convert a two-storey retail warehouse along the old N5 road at Drumindoo, Westport into a two-storey 24-hour gym.
Mayo County Council refused planning permission in January after expressing concern with the location of the site which is 2km from Westport town and claimed the development of a large gym at the proposed location would be contrary to the objectives of the Westport Local Area Plan.
Mr Cooley has appealed the decision to An Bord Pleanála and claimed that the local authority's decision was 'inappropriate' and cited the 'inconsistency' of the approach to this development compared to similar cases, which 'were all granted without difficulty'.
However, An Bord Pleanala reaffirmed the decision of the local authority to refuse planning stating that the location of the proposed new gym would 'constitute an unsustainable form of development dependent on car borne journeys'.
DM Fitness and Health who already operate two 24-hour gyms in Claremorris and Ballina had planned to move into the warehouse located adjacent to A O'Malley Carpets & Furniture.
The appeal which was prepared by Castlebar-based planning consultants, The Planning Partnership, stated that since the current County Development Plan was adopted in 2022, permission was granted to the applicant for a change of use of a warehouse outside Ballina into a 24-hour gym and no town centre concerns arose in this instance.
They also cited two similar cases on the Breaffy Road in Castlebar where no town centre concerns or issues over shared parking arose and they felt the same principle should also apply to Westport.
The owner of an existing gym which is located 300metres away from the appellant's location also made observations in the appeal.
Matthew Boccaccio of the 'The Republic of Fitness' stated that the two gyms in close proximity would create confusion for customers and pointed out that he is not allowed signage advertising his business which is located 90m off the old N5. He stated that Mr Cooley's business would be at a huge advantage given its prominence on the main road and this would likely lead to the closure of his business.
In addressing the observations of Mr Boccaccio, planning inspector with An Bord Pleanála, Ciarán Daly stated that while he noted the arguments, no significant planning issue had been raised and considered his observation to ‘be irrelevant to the consideration of the appeal'.
Mr Daly stated he noted the case put forward by the appellant in relation to the history of the site and the established retail use of the site but he had to consider 'broader sustainability issues' and have regard to 'sustainable travel considerations'.
“I consider the location for the proposed development outside the urban area of Westport in a rural area that would be unsustainable in terms of travel patterns required to access the facility. This approach would also support the settlement strategy and the sequential approach, where the development and revitalisation of Westport town is encouraged,” he wrote in his report to the Board of An Bord Pleanála.
He recommended that the appeal be refused on the grounds the location of the ‘proposed development on unzoned land outside the Westport town boundary in a rural area remote from areas of population and at a significant distance from existing housing and service centres’ would be contrary to the Mayo County Development Plan.
The Board of An Bord Pleanála followed the recommendations of Mr Daly and refused planning permission for the development.
