An Coimisiún Pleanála omit €58,000 footpath levy for west Mayo housing development

Mayo County Council had directed developer to pay €58,000 levy for footpath into Newport town centre
A MAYO developer has successfully overturned the inclusion of a €58,000 levy for a footpath as part of a housing project in Newport.
An Coimisiún Pleanála directed Mayo County Council to amend a planning condition and omit the need for developer Brendan Byrne & Son Ltd to pay a €58,000 levy for footpaths into Newport.
Mayo County Council had granted planning permission for seven detached dwelling units and two semi-detached dwelling units at Barrack Hill in Newport subject to 26 conditions.
One of the conditions included the provision for the payment of €36,280 as per the provisions of Class 1 of the Mayo Development Contribution Scheme 2023 along with an additional €58,800 for the provision of a section of footpath to ensure pedestrian connectivity with Newport town centre.
The developer appealed this condition to An Coimisiún Pleanála stating that the contribution of €58,800 was a mistake and 'should be omitted in its entirety due to the lack of evidential basis, lack of transparency, defined allocation within the scheme and precedent'.
The developer also claimed that 'extortionate fees' will only make the housing crisis worse and they were not sure if the development is viable with these additional costs.
In his report to An Coimisiún Pleanála, Ciarán Daly, Planning Inspector outlined that the calculation of the €58,000 levy is based on footpath length but noted the contribution scheme charge is based on a permitted residential development of nine dwellings and no part of the scheme is based on the length of a footpath required by the planning authority.
Therefore, he said he did not consider there to be a basis for charging the €58,800 amount and recommended this be omitted.
Mr Daly also reviewed the calculation for the Mayo Development Contribution Scheme and as a result considered that the amount due under Class 1 of the contribution scheme for nine residential units to be €29,898 and not €36,280.
“I do not consider that the omission of the €58,800 amount would prevent the funding of the 210 metres of footpath to connect with the town. Therefore, I am satisfied that the €58,800 amount charged for the provision of a section of footpath to ensure pedestrian connectivity with Newport town centre has no planning or legal basis under the development contribution scheme.
“I therefore am of the opinion that the correct development contribution calculation basis, consistent with the development contribution scheme, is €29,898 with indexation as per the provisions of Class 1 of the contribution scheme and that there is no basis for an additional contribution charge, whether for footpaths or otherwise,” he stated before recommending to amend the condition to reduce the sum due in to €29,898.
The Commission generally agreed with the recommendation of Mr Daly and directed that the amount of €58,800 for the provision of a section of a footpath shall be omitted from the planning condition.
