Westport men appear in court following violent assaults
A Westport man appeared before the local district court charged with the slashing in the face of well-known sports star
Westport men appear in court after violent assaults on well-known sportsman
Edwin McGreal
A Westport man appeared before the local district court last week charged with the slashing in the face of well-known local rugby and Gaelic football player David Keane.
Stephen Ruane of 11, Cloonmonad Close, Westport was charged with Section 4 assault and a lesser charge, Section 3 assault, arising out of an incident at the Castlecourt Hotel on the night of December 2 last.
As a result of the attack, which occurred after a charity boxing event at the hotel, Mr Keane required hospital surgery and received around 40 stitches, both internally and externally, to his face.
Ruane was charged with Section 4 assault - intentionally or recklessly causing serious harm - and a Section 3 assault - to assault another causing harm - for offences on the same night.
Two other local men were also charged with offences arising from the same night. David Gibbons of 18, Cloonmonad Close, Westport was charged with Section 3 assault on David Keane while Danny Ring of 13, Cloonmonad Close was charged with two public order offences on that night.
All three men were arrested on Thursday morning last, shortly before Westport District Court sat after the Director of Public Prosecutions directed that Ruane and Gibbons be sent forward for trial on indictment - meaning the case will eventually be heard in the Circuit Court.
Inspector Barry Foley told Judge Aeneas McCarthy that he was objecting to bail in relation to Ruane and Gibbons. Gardaí had objected to bail for a Section 3 assault the previous day against Ring, however that application was refused at Castlebar District Court.
Inspector Foley told the court that his reason for objecting to bail for Ruane was because of the severity of the charge and also cited the likelihood of re-offence, telling the court that Ruane was subsequently charged with an assault last month and had appeared before Castlebar District Court the previous day for that charge. He also cited past bench warrants being issued against Ruane as a reason for dismissing bail.
Inspector Foley cited the seriousness of the charge against Gibbons as the chief reason for refusing bail.
However, acceding to bail, Judge McCarthy said that a flight risk had to be proven and, that in relation to the seriousness of the offence, bail had been granted before for charges such as murder, rape and armed robbery.
All three men were given strict bail conditions. They have to sign on at the local Garda Station every Monday, Wednesday and Friday between 9am and 7pm; they must obey a curfew between 9pm and 9am daily; they must abstain for all intoxicants and must not interfere with the injured party or any of the witnesses.
Ruane was ordered to bail on his own bond of €1,000 and an independent surety of €3,000. One third of this had to be lodged in cash to the court. However Ruane didn’t provide the independent surety and was remanded in custody to appear before Harristown District Court (Castlerea) the following day (Friday). There the surety wasn’t paid and it is understand that Ruane is set to appeal the size of the surety to the High Court today (Tuesday). It means he was remanded in custody from last Thursday until today, pending the issue at High Court level.
Bail was fixed for Gibbons on his own bond of €1,000 and an independent surety of €1,800. This surety was paid later in the court sitting by his uncle, John Gibbons. Bail was fixed for Ring on his own bond of €500.
All three are due to return before Westport District Court on June 17 next when a book of evidence is expected to be served.
Defendants charged with second assault
Stephen Ruane and Danny Ring were also in court the previous day (Wednesday), this time at Castlebar District Court, where they were ordered to stay away from each other after they were both charged with alleged assault causing harm. The court heard the man injured in the assault was now afraid to leave his home.
Danny Ring and Stephen Ruane were arrested on Wednesday, June 2 at 7.30am and brought to Westport Garda Station, where they were both charged with alleged section 3 assault on Mr Damien Maloney at Cherry Tree Avenue, Westport on May 21 last. Neither made any reply after being charged.
The two men were then brought to a sitting of Castlebar District Court where an application was made to remand Mr Ring in custody. Inspector Martin Byrne explained that on three occasions bench warrants had to be issued against him after he failed to appear in court and he was afraid witnesses would be interfered with.
Garda Feargal Caheny explained that a statement has been made that the injured parties family had been approached and believed there would be interference with the injured party. He added that the victim was an active member of the community before the assault but was afraid to leave his house to such an extent that he will not leave it to get any help.
Mr James Ward, solicitor for Mr Ring said his client had given an undertaking that he would not go near the victim and objected to the application to remand Mr Ring in custody.
Judge Aeneas McCarthy said he would grant Mr Ring bail on his own bond of €300 on the conditions he keeps to a curfew from 9pm to 9am, signs on daily in Westport Garda Station, reside at his current address, not interfere with the injured party of family, keep away from his co-defendant Mr Ruane and abstain from alcohol and drugs.
Mr Ward claimed that it will be difficult from him not to keep away from Mr Ruane as they were neighbours but Judge McCarthy told him to cross the road if there is a chance of them meeting. Similar bail conditions were attached to Mr Ruane.