Twenty officers raided waste companies offices
ON the fourth day of the trial of former Mayo County Secretary Padraic Hughes and three west of Ireland waste disposal operators last Friday
Twenty officers raided waste companies offices
Trial hears evidence that accused operators co-operated fully with investigation
Ann Healy
Galway
ON the fourth day of the trial of former Mayo County Secretary Padraic Hughes and three west of Ireland waste disposal operators last Friday, Competition Authority officers gave evidence of raiding the premises of all three companies and the private house of Mr Hughes, simultaneously between 9.30 and 11 a.m. on February 22, 2005.
Former officer, Patrick O’Neill gave evidence that twenty officers came from Dublin the night before and raided all four premises that morning accompanied by a garda.
All of the defendants were very co-operative and handed over any documents they held in relation to the formation of BGM Waste. and that company’s proposed tender.
Mr Paddy McGrath told the search party there were no relevant documents at his premises but he rang his accountant, Mr James Jennings, who had formed BGM Waste Ltd in the days before the tender was submitted, and told him to hand over his file to the competition officers, which he duly did.
Mr O’Neill, when cross-examined by Mr Patrick Gageby SC representing Mr Hughes, admitted that a search warrant served on Mr Hughes that morning by officer Ray Leonard was technically flawed and that when he and Mr Leonard returned to his home later that afternoon to return documents to him regarding BGM Ltd unlawfully seized that morning, he had told them they could keep them and had been more than helpful to them in that regard.
Officer Ray Leonard gave evidence that when he called to Mr Hughes house that morning Mr Hughes had told them there was no need to search the house before handing over a box of documents to them. They had offered to return the documents once they discovered the search warrant was invalid but Mr Hughes told them to keep them.
Mr O’Neill said the file seized from Mr Hughes contained documents showing the three company directors’ agreement over the proposed division of County Council customers between them for the entire Co Mayo and he read out the proposed routes which showed a three-way division of the county between the three companies.
Mr Jennings had told the trial beforehand that he had been instructed around August 24, 2005, by his long-time client, Mr Paddy McGrath to form BGM Waste Ltd in the days leading to the tender deadline on September 2, 2005 and that he felt under a lot of pressure to get the terms of the company just right.
He said he had concerns about how the company might operate as it was going to involve four different companies all coming together to submit one tender. He said he was formed a limited company and that when Mr Monaghan withdrew on August 30 he went ahead and divided the shares between the remaining three companies.
He read into evidence hand-written notes he had made to himself at the time regarding his idea of how the company might operate and his concerns on how the asset (the Co Mayo customer date base) might be divided between the shareholders in the future.
He said his view was that the new company would be owned by Mr McGrath at first and if its tender was accepted it would be divided out between the shareholding companies by profit sharing or else by sale of the data base later on. He proposed that the new company would sell off routes and the customers that came with them to the shareholders.
He read out a proposed breakdown of the areas each company was to service. “After that I proceeded to form a limited company with shareholdings and that was the last of it,” Mr. Jennings added.
The trial continues this week.