Travellers attacked pub with iron bars
Three travellers were sentenced to a total of seven years for causing nearly €5,000 worth of damage to a Kilkelly pub.
Travellers attacked pub with iron bars
THREE Travellers who smashed the windows of a pub in Kilkelly, causing nearly €5,000 worth of damage, after they were refused entry were sentenced to a total of seven years imprisonment at last week’s sitting of Castlebar Circuit Criminal Court.
Mr William Carthy of 2 Airport Road, Kilkelly; Mr Thomas McDonagh (22) of Kilcun, Kiltimagh, and Mr Thomas Maughan (21) of Kilcun, Kiltimagh, pleaded guilty to the offences which took place outside Shazzy Mac’s Bar in Kilkelly on November 9, 2007. The court heard how a piece of wood broken from a bench was used by the three men to threaten patrons at the bar and that iron bars were used by two of the men to break 14 windows in the pub and cars parked outside.
Judge Raymond Groarke describe the events as ‘mindless acts of terrorism’ and said the behaviour of the three men, along with a minority of others in the Traveller community, resulted in discrimination against other Travellers.
“We are all responsible for our own actions and it is acts like this that bring your community into disrepute. We are all representatives of a community...and if I behaved like that, I would be discriminated against and rightly so,” he said.
Detective Garda Martin Mitchell told the court that the three men were involved in a minor incident when they left another pub in Kilkelly at 10.55pm, and as a result were denied entry to Shazzy Mac’s Bar by the owner Sharon Duffy – who was pregnant at the time – who blocked their entry.
Det Garda Mitchell said that Mr McDonagh, who was bare-chested, and Mr Carthy attempted to pull her from the doorway but she was rescued by her partner John McSharry and they were joined by locals who blocked the doorway. He said Mr Maughan kicked out at the people in the doorway and a pint glass which was thrown narrowly missed Mr McSharry. Mr McDonagh and Mr Maughan then broke up a wooden bench and used the timber as weapons and attempted to hit people.
He explained that Mr Maughan was then given an empty beer barrel by Mr Carthy and threw it in the direction of the doorway. Det Garda Mitchell said they continued to beckon the local people to fight with them and attempted to kick out at a number of people.
The three men left the area but Mr Maughan and Mr McDonagh arrived soon after with iron bars which forced people to lock themselves into the bar. The two men then broke 14 windows in the pub and the windscreens of five cars were also broken. Det Garda Mitchell said that Mr Carthy directed and encouraged the two other defendants and handed them timber, and was uncooperative when he was arrested.
He explained that all three men had previous convictions and had no history of employment. Det Garda Mitchell said that a total of €4,633.95 of damage was caused to the pub on the night and €920 damage was caused to one car. CCTV footage of the incident was shown to the court.
Mr John Hannon BL, for Mr Carthy (instructed by Mr Alan Gannon) said that, earlier in the evening, Mr Carthy had been called a ‘knacker’ and ‘tinker’ and he suggested that this was something that caused the row. He said that Mr Carthy had lived in Kilkelly with his family but he said there was a history of discrimination against him and his family and they had to move to Castlerea.
Mr Hannon said his client entered an early plea, even though there was ‘clear evidence’ that he was at the periphery of the incidents and did not strike a blow. Mr Hannon explained that his client had five children and was trying to deal with his alcohol problem and go on the straight and narrow.
Mr Diarmuid Connolly BL, for Mr McDonagh and Mr Maughan (instructed by Mr John Gordon), said his clients had not come to the attention of the Gardaí since the incident and were addressing their drink problems. He added that not many probation reports hold out hope for people as their reports do for them and said that, with the help of the Probation Services, they could turn away from criminality.
Judge Raymond Groarke said it was frightening to look at the video of the CCTV footage and described the incident as a ‘riot’ and ‘outrageous violence’. He said it was only by good fortune that it did not result in extreme injuries and he had no alternative but to send them to prison.
However, he said he was willing to give them a chance to prove to him and society that they were prepared to change and would suspend part of their sentence.
He sentenced Mr Carthy to two years’ imprisonment but suspended the final 18 months on the condition he keep the peace for three years after he is released. He also ordered that he come under the supervision of the Probation Services and that he not commit any crime or consume any alcohol or drugs.
He sentenced both Mr Maughan and Mr McDonagh to three years’ imprisonment but suspended the final 27 months on the same conditions as Mr Carthy. He warned the men if they committed any crime, they would be back in prison to serve the full term.